Not directly commenting to you guys, but generally about that "PP-specialist" narrative. Let's check all time great goal scorers whom scored 500 or more in their respective careers. The group is not big, but it is all time best in regular season goal scoring all hypoteticals left aside. Simplest way to look to their degree of "PP specialism" is just take PP goal percentage of their total goals scored. The list ordered by amount of goals scored:
800, 700, and 600 Goals Clubs
Gretzky________22.8%
Howe_________26.3%
Jagr__________ 28.3%
Brett Hull______ 35.8%
Dionne________ 32.0%
Esposito_______34.3%
Gartner________30.6%
Ovechkin_______37.3%
Messier________25.8%
Yzerman_______29.2%
Lemieux_______34.2%
Selänne________37.3%
Robitaille_______37.0%
Shanahan_______36.1%
Andreychuk_____42.8%
Sakic__________32.8%
Bobby Hull______25.2%
Ciccarelli_______38.2%
Kurri__________25.8%
500 Goals Club
Recchi_________34.7%
Bossy__________31.4%
Niewendyk______38.1%
Sundin_________28.4%
Modano________28.0%
Marleau________30.3%
Lafleur_________27.5%
Bucyk__________28.6%
Francis_________34.2%
Goulet__________32.7%
Richard_________26.3%
Mikita__________27.7%
Tkachuk________39.4%
Mahovlich_______22.9%
Hossa__________27.2%
Trottier_________20.7%
Verbeek_________35.6%
Hawerchuk_______35.1%
Turgeon_________36.9%
Roenick_________35.9%
Perreault________26.2%
Beliveau________34.1%
Bondra_________29.6%
Mullen_________29.9%
McDonald_______27.8%
The core of problem of so called PP-specialism is that nobody, like ever when making HFB comment, determine what he/she means when PP-specialist tag is applied to some player (honestly or with intent to use it as an argument of bad faith). Its clear that Alex Ovechkin is "PP Specialist" relatively, objectively. But if he is that whom else are too when using same criteria? Lemieux, Selänne, Brett Hull, Esposito, Robitaille, Shanahan, Andreychuk, Ciccarelli, Recchi, Niewendyk, Francis, Tkatchuk, Verbeek, Hawechuk, Turgeon, Roenick, Beliveau are PP specialist too, if OV is. But how about Sakic, Marleau, Bondra, Dionne, Gartner, just to mention few?
What exactly is the minimum threshold for someone to be considered PP-specialist? 30% of goals? Or do "PP-specialist" need more than 40% to be true PP-wizard? If we factor in PP TOI, does PP G/60 impact to the degree of PP specialism also?
And, the last but not least, how exactly someone being prolific in scoring power play goals can ever be considered as something that would lower a player's goal scoring resume? It seems that using that tag with bad faith will dump a lot of **** over many legendary all time greats in NHL goal scoring.
In this relative comparison, not that surprisingly it is The Great One who survive best from that alleged PP-specialism ****.