I love McQuaid, and we are seeing how good he looks healthy. The only problem is how long can he stay healthy? With the lack of an enforcer type, McQ would be one of the guys picking up the slack in the fighting department and he certainly is capable. This is a plus in his favor, although if the B's kept Robins as the 13th F, it would negate some of that. The problem for McQ is that Miller has a very similar skillset and costs half the $$.
Another interesting area is the opposite spot (3rd pair Left side). This is a spot that we all assumed was going to be manned by Krug for the foreseeable future. However, now Krug is not in camp, and both Warsofsky and Bart have looked good playing there. Personally, I think there is a drop off from Krug to either of those guys offensively, but at what point does Chia start to look at the salaries and the performance and start weighing the Pros and Cons? Bart only makes $1.2m, and Warsofsky half of that at $600k. I don't see Krug being dealt and I think guys like Bart and DW playing well just gives the B's more leverage with Krug.
Some extremely interesting decisions need to be made in the next couple of weeks.
While no doubt giving many of us ulcers I have to give credit to Peter Chiarelli for not blinking concerning having a knee jerk reaction to Marchand's (among others) poor playoffs and Krug's agent (supposedly) whispering the rumor about there being interest from the KHL. In years past Harry and MOC would've ranted and traded just to watch him end up playing for Montreal and burning us for the next 5-6 years. He's not gonna shoot until he see's the whites of their eyes no matter who says or does whatever.