Proposal: 5 trades involving Pacioretty (NYI, DAL, OTT, CGY, PHI, TB)

[WatchfulElm]

I totally expect they will all be heavily rejected, as it's the tradition on HFBoards. Have fun!


- Anthony Beauvillier
- 2020 Islanders 1st round draft pick


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Brett Lernout

-----------------------

- Jason Spezza
- Julius Honka
- 2020 Stars 1st round draft pick


- Erik Karlsson


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Mattias Janmark
- Charlie Lindgren
- 2019 Canadiens 3nd round draft pick

-----------------------

- Troy Brouwer (for buy out)
- Sam Bennett
- 2020 1st round pick
- Jon Gillies


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Charlie Lindgren

-------------------------

- Andrew MacDonald
- Travis Sanheim


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Victor Mete

-----------------------

- 2020 Lightning 1st round draft pick
- Mathieu Joseph
- Slater Koekkoek
- Ryan Callahan (for buy out)


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Brett Lernout

Click to read more...

 

[LordZapp]

Hell no from the lightning.

 

[CornerStone61]

Sens get bent

 

[Jray42]

No thank you from Philly.

 

[Iceman]

Sens get bent

That one was hilarious. If they trade Karlsson they want youth with a good shot at making the NHL be it a 1st line player or a #3 dman.

 

[admiralcadillac]

In before a deluge of fans from other teams criticizing Pacioretty

 

[CupHolders]

As an Islander fan I’d rather keep Beauvillier much less add a pick.

Patches is good. But he doesn’t fill a need.

 

[bukwas]

Flames might want to take a break from trading picks for awhile. That one is more of a finishing touch type move when they should be focused on strengthening the foundation.

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Damn, those some terrible proposals.

Dude thinks Pacioretty is Crosby I think

 

[Thrasymachus]

how in the world does Beauvillier + our 1st round pick = Pacioretty

 

[Sky04]

Tampa one isn't completely horrible but Patches isn't the player we need.

A 1st to ditch Callahan's cap, and KK+Joseph for a signed 5 x 30 goal scorer, value actually leans towards the Lightning.

 

[blankall]

F-no from Calgary.

We have no room for Pacioretty. We have a log jam of goalie prospects in our system. Several are better than Lindgren, including Gillies.

We do not have any reason to dump cap. We are definitely not giving up our 2020 1st and/or Bennett.

Not only does this not fit the needs of Calgary in any way whatsoever, but it's a moot point as you are not getting a sign and trade on Pacioretty. If the Flames do decide they have a need for Pacioretty, they sign him for free next off season.

Horrible horrible proposal OP.

 

[MSSLYNX]

In before a deluge of fans from other teams criticizing Pacioretty

Saying no to Getting Max as main piece in a Karlsson trade is not criticizing him, its just being real.

 

[Mackiaveli]

- Anthony Beauvillier
- 2020 Islanders 1st round draft pick


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Brett Lernout

Habs lose this deal.

- Jason Spezza
- Julius Honka
- 2020 Stars 1st round draft pick


- Erik Karlsson


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Mattias Janmark
- Charlie Lindgren
- 2019 Canadiens 3nd round draft pick

Spezza doesn't want to go to Canada, Ottawa gets raked over the coals for this one.

- Troy Brouwer (for buy out)
- Sam Bennett
- 2020 1st round pick
- Jon Gillies


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Charlie Lindgren

Don't think either team wants to do this, but value is right.

- Andrew MacDonald
- Travis Sanheim


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Victor Mete

Flyers fans won't agree to this despite getting way more value. Sanheim is supposed to be a top pair guy in the future so they're going to value him at his projected value not his current value. Don't think Habs walk out of this the winners unless Sanheim turns into that #2 guy, so kind of a wash.

- 2020 Lightning 1st round draft pick
- Mathieu Joseph
- Slater Koekkoek
- Ryan Callahan (for buy out)


- Max Pacioretty (signed)
- Brett Lernout

Habs would probably want Johnson instead of Callahan, or Cal Foote over Koekkoek.

None of those packages are really worth a signed Pacioretty.

 

[CupHolders]

how in the world does Beauvillier + our 1st round pick = Pacioretty

Thing is many opposing fans don’t realize that Beauvillier scored most of his goals the second half of the year. He already has 30 goal potential.

 

[YP44]

The Flames one looks decent IMO however top 6 in Calgary now pretty full.

 

[Captain97]

how in the world does Beauvillier + our 1st round pick = Pacioretty

Pacioretty extended is extremely valuable a middle six winger ( top six potential) + a 1st is probably rental value for patches.

 

[Thrasymachus]

Habs lose this deal.

.

No way Patches is worth Beauvillier let alone with our first included, lol

 

[Kcb12345]

Yes from the Stars no takebacks

 

[Thrasymachus]

Pacioretty extended is extremely valuable a middle six winger ( top six potential) + a 1st is probably rental value for patches.

Okay? Beauvillier is an extremely valuable middle six CENTER who is younger?

 

[Spotty 2 Hotty]

No. The Stars lose 2/3rds of their 2nd line with Janmark and Spezza going and they've already got shit forward depth.

 

[migi]

That Flyers deal though. Sanheim and Mete are pretty even at this point so Pacioretty = MacDonald?

 

[Mackiaveli]

you are not getting a sign and trade on Pacioretty

You kind of were alright until you said that

If the Flames do decide they have a need for Pacioretty, they sign him for free next off season.

Ah, herein lies the issue. You're deluded enough into thinking that if they Flames DECIDE they want Max, they'll be the only team so they can just wait until the off-season.

Weird how teams are scrapping it out for Erik Karlsson and there's going to be massive pieces going back (rightfully so) but for a 30+ goal scorer teams will just "wait it out" and "get him for free"

You're an idiot.

 

[WatchfulElm]

Habs lose this deal.




Spezza doesn't want to go to Canada, Ottawa gets raked over the coals for this one.



Don't think either team wants to do this, but value is right.




Flyers fans won't agree to this despite getting way more value. Sanheim is supposed to be a top pair guy in the future so they're going to value him at his projected value not his current value. Don't think Habs walk out of this the winners unless Sanheim turns into that #2 guy, so kind of a wash.




Habs would probably want Johnson instead of Callahan, or Cal Foote over Koekkoek.

None of those packages are really worth a signed Pacioretty.

Thanks for your balanced criticism. We don't often see this on this trade board, where unproven prospects always have more value than established star players.

 

[Mackiaveli]

No way Patches is worth Beauvillier let alone with our first included, lol

Patches, a career 30+ goal scorer, who has a 37 and 39 goal season under his belt since the lockout shortened season ---- is worth less than a 3rd line C who has had 24 and 36 POINT seasons?

You're kidding, right?