Striiker
Earthquake Survivor
Not so much "luck" as a split second action between two players. Not the most consistent or replicable thing. Even the best guys are typically only around 50%, hence "coinflip".I agree with most stuff you say, but I think you're way off here.
Some players don't shoot 50 to 60 percent regularly because of luck and guys like Voracek don't have low percentages constantly because of luck. It's not exactly small sample sizes with a guy like Voracek.
Shootouts are their own skill, essentially breakaway abilities in a controlled environment without the panic or adrenaline rush that occurs in a game. Voracek doesn't do well because he always does the same move, has a relatively weak shot, and is bad at the shootout. Other players tend to do well because they have an insane shot or because they're very creative and unpredictable with what they're going to do on top of puck handling skills.
We're historically a bad shootout team, with largely the same veteran forward core. Not just coincidence we're always at the bottom of the league with it.
But meh... alright, even if we say that Voracek shouldn't go, it's not like Farabee and JVR should be locks. Plus, Patrick has been our 2nd best this year so far, statistically speaking.
Regardless, it's honestly not something I have real strong feelings about in general. I was more just trying to point out it's not one of the things I think is worth harping on too much. It's not like any of them are aces who MUST go.