I posted this elsewhere on the forum but I’d do
Nylander to DET
Karlsson 25% retained, Johansson to TOR
Berggren, Lombardi, Maatta, 2025 1st to SJS
Gotta give to get
lombardi would hurt a lot more tbh. I would hate to get rid of berggren, especially because I think he would be a great setup man for debrincat, but it is what it is.
Lombardi I doubt they move. We should replace him with Doucet or someone in that realm. SJS needs a whole lot so I don't see how they would be that worked up over it. I would just hate to see lombardi get traded before we see what he's got in AHL first. At least a handful of games. Maatta would also suck but I get it. At least that would give the room for Ed to get in.
Even with getting rid of nylander, I don't see how they can get karlsson, even with retention. Jarnkrok/Kampf need to be traded to really make it work. So, I guess that would help in this trade and instead of lombardi/doucet, sjs could get kampf/jarnkrok? Because Nylander isn't the big name in this trade you listed and we seem to be giving up everything.
DET
Nylander
TOR
Karlsson 25% retained
ALJO/Viro
SJS
Berggren
Maatta
2024/25 1st (DET, depends on how the BOS pick works out)
2025 3rd (TOR for taking jarnkrok dump?)
Kampf/Jarnkrok
From what I have seen on the trade forums is TOR fans just want to dump Jarnkrok. With these figures, TOR lowers that cap roughly 500k or so if ALJO/Viro start in AHL. If you did Kampf, then it would lower their cap hit by another 300k so roughly 800k. They are still over the cap though.
TOR may need to add another pick or something to get that retention closer to 40% (I thought I saw somewhere that SJS is now willing to do that?). If that is the case, they would lower their cap hit by 2.1mil with jarnkrok and 2.4mil with kampf. I think this would help TOR out the most and if I am reading capfriendly correctly, that would take them 100k under the cap (maybe check that for me lol)
Either rate, SJS will get a pretty good size haul for a player and org that don't want an 11.5mil player anymore. Would much prefer viro going because i think ALJO is going to be exceptional.