Howdy all! I finally gave in and created an account after lurking on this site for a few weeks. I'd lost interest in the Hawks during the past couple years and gotta say it's nice to have some good young players like Dach and Kubalik to get excited about once again. Now I'm hooked again haha!
I think this offseason and the next 12 months are going to be crucial in determining the Hawks future trajectory, and I've got some bold ideas about what management should do to turn the team into a contender again. I'm still lining up my thoughts and will probably share them in a long post once the Hawks' season is over, but in the meantime I will say that I think the brass should look to keep Kubalik and Strome over Saad and Debrincat when it comes to next season's roster. In fact, even though it would make us worse in the short term I would actively try to trade Saad (with retention if necessary) for a 1st round pick/high-end prospect and Cat for a pick in the 5-10 range in this year's draft.
My reasoning for the above is this:
1. Kubalik looks like a stud, so do whatever is necessary to keep him with the Hawks long term.
2. I see Strome as a player who is improving and stands a decent chance of reaching his potential of a good 2C. Plus, the cost to resign him should be favorable relative to his overall performance.
3. We need to shed salary for next season, and two-way top 6 players like Saad are always in demand. Plus he's a pending UFA, and IMO there's a good chance he would be open to resigning with us after the 2020-21 season even if we traded him.
4. I see Cat as a 30/60-ish 2nd line player on a contender. However I also feel his defensive and puck-retrieval skills are below average due to his lack of size, reach, and bulk. 6.4 million per year is around market value for that kind of production, but based on the general scouting consensus the top 10 picks from this year's draft seem likely to turn into players who will equal or exceed Cat's overall contribution - it would take 2-3 years for them to reach that level, sure, but I think trading Cat for a high pick would make the team better in the long run.