StevenToddIves
Registered User
@StevenToddIves
I’ve seen Podkolzin ranked as high as 3 by various reputable scouts. We haven’t been pumping his tires much on this forum but...could you see a scenario in which Shero/Castron selects him over Cozens/Byram? Nothing against the kid but I’d be extremely disappointed as I feel Cozens and Byram have more overall upside and check much greater organizational needs. The notorious “Russian factor” also scares me.
Same question if we miss out on picking top 4- do you see Shero/Castron going with Podkolzin over the likes of Turcotte or Zegras?
An aside- as you previously mentioned...if Devils fans want Byram, I completely agree we better hope Vancouver or Detroit is not picking at 3 or 4 (if he’s still on the board and we are picking after them). I think Los Angeles or Anaheim is much more likely to take Cozens or Podkolzin over Byram whereas Vancouver and Detroit really need to add D to their pipeline. I’m having lots of very bizarre fun tracking the out-of-town scoreboard these days.
Thanks again for all your terrific work and insight!
Podkolzin is a terrific player. He reminds me of a Tkachuk brother, with an insane mix of skill, power and grit. I have him in my top 10 but not my top 4, however. This is not because I have any doubts about him, so much as I just like players like Byram and Cozens a bit more. If Podkolzin has any weaknesses it's that he's a pretty good skater, not a great one, and though his scoring ability is truly elite, he is good but not great in terms of passing/on-ice vision. I see him as a surefire first-liner, but not a winger who can drive play (like Kakko or Krebs). That being said, he plays with enticing physicality and has an advanced 200-foot game.
The reason I personally believe he will not be at the top of the Devils draft list is threefold. First, the Devils brass of Shero and Castron have clearly placed an emphasis on team speed. Many of the other players ranked around him -- Byram, Cozens, Turcotte, Zegras, Krebs -- can absolutely fly. Though Kakko is also not exactly a speed demon, he is universally considered a tier above the next group of players to be drafted, and drives possession as well as finishes. Secondly, there is some uncertainty as to when Podkolzin will come to North America. If he were to sign a KHL deal, it could be 2022-23 before his drafting team gets him in camp. This uncertainty is definitely going to be on the mind of any team which considers him. We're not talking Andrei Svechnikov, who played in the OHL and said repeatedly he wanted to ply his trade in the NHL as soon as possible. Lastly, though every GM always talks up the "best available player" game, the Devils have glaring organizational needs at pretty much every position except left-shooting winger. They need LD, RD, C and right-shooting wingers.
Personally, my rankings are never exactly the same as my list of players I want on the Devils. I also have Matthew Boldy ranked quite highly, but, like Podkolzin, he is not the best fit for the NJ organization.
I believe you are absolutely correct that the three teams most likely to take Byram in the #3-#5 range are the Devils, Vancouver and Detroit. Most teams, in my estimation, would decide between Cozens/Podkolzin/Dach at #3. I believe the most likely #3 overall pick is Cozens. Even NJ and Detroit would likely strongly consider Cozens at #3, even if eventually going with Byram. I think the only team who is an absolute lock to take Byram at #3 would be Vancouver.
To answer your final question to the best of my ability, I think you are asking essentially: "who do the Devils take at #5 or #6 overall if Cozens and Byram are both off the table?"
I still would not take Podkolzin here. My rankings (for the Devils, not my personal rankings) after the top 4 are:
5)Turcotte
6)Zegras
7)Krebs
8)Newhook
9)Podkolzin
10)Boldy
That being said, if the Devils took Podkolzin or Boldy at #5 or #6 it would not be a disappointment. They're both simply outstanding prospects. I'd just rather have Turcotte/Zegras, I think they fit in better with what the Devils need and what they are trying to do.