I was at the game. The second goal was very weak by Desjardins. Took the air out of the team.
Quick synopsis:
McIlrath was the best defenseman on the ice. He is a defensive dman. He has multiple occasions where he absolutely man handled other players. Whether it was people trying to hit him or him hitting other people. He uses his stick very well and is a good PKer.
Miller and Fast were the most noticeable forwards pretty easily. Miller's strength is very evident. Fast is NHL ready right now. Quick. Smart. Solid offensively and defensively. He created the Packs second goal by beating a defenseman with a it of a change of pace outside and centering the puck. Really nice play.
Lindberg looks very good on both ends of the ice. Offensively his shot he had was beautiful. Defensively he is strong and knows his positioning very well. I would say that if he isn't NHL ready right now, he will be very soon. You have to really watch him play to understand his understated play.
Tommy Hughes was impressive. More impressive than from what I remember. Solid. Calm: physical. RD who was playing both sides throughout the game. He finished his checks when available but he was very solid in his own end. Good breakout passes. I see the Girardi comparisons. Solid positionally and understated game.
Hrivik is very good along the boards. Strong and knows the offensive side. Will his offensive game show is the question.
The Bourques were very good. Quickness is amazing in both. Ryan looks like the better overall player and is far more physical.
Kristo showed flashes. He needs to show consistency.
I specifically watched McIlrath every shift. For the people who say he isn't progressing, ********. You obviously don't watch him. He is preocresaong nicely. He looked like Brayden Coburn.
Sigh. Wish we had more players who were preocresaong nicely.
I was at the game. The second goal was very weak by Desjardins. Took the air out of the team.
Quick synopsis:
McIlrath was the best defenseman on the ice. He is a defensive dman. He has multiple occasions where he absolutely man handled other players. Whether it was people trying to hit him or him hitting other people. He uses his stick very well and is a good PKer.
Miller and Fast were the most noticeable forwards pretty easily. Miller's strength is very evident. Fast is NHL ready right now. Quick. Smart. Solid offensively and defensively. He created the Packs second goal by beating a defenseman with a it of a change of pace outside and centering the puck. Really nice play.
Lindberg looks very good on both ends of the ice. Offensively his shot he had was beautiful. Defensively he is strong and knows his positioning very well. I would say that if he isn't NHL ready right now, he will be very soon. You have to really watch him play to understand his understated play.
Tommy Hughes was impressive. More impressive than from what I remember. Solid. Calm: physical. RD who was playing both sides throughout the game. He finished his checks when available but he was very solid in his own end. Good breakout passes. I see the Girardi comparisons. Solid positionally and understated game.
Hrivik is very good along the boards. Strong and knows the offensive side. Will his offensive game show is the question.
The Bourques were very good. Quickness is amazing in both. Ryan looks like the better overall player and is far more physical.
Kristo showed flashes. He needs to show consistency.
I specifically watched McIlrath every shift. For the people who say he isn't progressing, ********. You obviously don't watch him. He is preocresaong nicely. He looked like Brayden Coburn.
A lot of interesting information. Personally I think McIlrath would be playing for some NHL teams if he belonged to them. The Rangers are solid on the right side with Girardi, Boyle and Klein. No room at the moment and I'm not sure how AV views him. I wouldn't be surprised if the right deal came along that the Rangers move him. I think they'd want something tangible back--they won't dump him. He continues to make progress. Even when he finally makes it he should continue to improve as he moves towards his mid and late 20's.
Hughes sounds interesting. I know Beacon likes him a lot. He's young and has an excellent build to play a physical brand of hockey.
There's been a few games this year where Hrivik has had 0 shots on goal. Overall he has only 10 shots on goal in 11 games played. Is he always playing a regular shift? IMO he'll never be an offensive threat at the NHL level if he's not going to be much of a threat at the AHL level. A boards and corner player with good size. Tanner Glass without nearly the physical element.
What language is this word supposed to be from?
Hrivik was playing a regular shift on what I would consider the 4th line. He doesn't seem to be near the goal a lot but he wins puck battles quite a bit.
Haggerty is the guy I left out. He was playing with Fast and Miller. His shot is a weapon and he knows it. He get to where he needs to but his skating needs a bit of work. He is very strong on his skates.
He had one play where he took the puck wide and beat the defenseman and drove right through the crease. I like to see that. Take the puck to the net.
I believe Potulny is injured. He got rocked by Carrick last night in the corner. Kind of a bit of a dirty play IMO.
huh
Didn't realize Skapski was with the Pack
(not counting today) how's he doing?
The problem with McIlrath is that he's low on the depth chart.
I've personally never had an issue with his game. If he was a 3rd or 4th round pick he'd be viewed differently. The results are the same in terms of what he has done in the CHL and AHL.
The Rangers need to admit that they are doing him a disservice by keeping him in the minors because there is no chance he ever cracks the top-4 with both Klein and Girardi locked up long term.
Trade the kid. They drafted him off emotion from a season in which they were pushed around every night. He needs a chance, but he won't get it with a Cup Contender. I think he's earned it. Staff obviously feels otherwise.
He's literally two seasons away from getting another chance to earn a top-6 spot.
He'll be 24.
Prime of his career and still a minor leaguer fighting for the chance to play 12 mins a night.
I do believe the best option at this point is to move McIlrath. As you said, there's little chance that there's an opening on defense for him to truly win anytime in the near future. And given what we ask our defensemen to do in our system, he's not even a good fit. To move him now wouldn't exactly be selling high, however, leaving him to languish in the AHL for another year or more certainly won't do anything to improve his stock. It's probably best for both McIlrath and the organization to simply move on.
Regardless of whether or not he ever becomes an NHL regular, I'm sure at some point down the road he will absolutely wreck Rick Nash or Marty St. Louis or someone. Just because that's how it works.
I definitely understand the argument that McIlrath deserves a shot elsewhere. The only thing that bothers me is our need for size on defense, still very much exists. And I still believe that is the reason we lost in the SCF.
Miller is a legit star right now at the AHL level. He has youth, size, strength--seems to have the willingness but hasn't been able to solidify an NHL roster spot with the Rangers and to be honest at this point I like Hayes better. Hayes hasn't put up much as far as stats but he's always creating chances.
Not the only reason but the biggest IMO.
The issue is where he fits, who does he replace etc. It's hard to justify taking any of the top-6 out for him.
But I like what I see in Hartford. If he plays well they can include him in a package for a guy like Sekera, but like nyr2k2 said, the last thing I want is him traded in the conference, let alone the division.