After the trade deadline, teams are allowed 4 non-emergency call-ups until the AHL teams finish their seasons. On March 11th the Avs called up Malone and Carey. There are 2. On March 19th Carey got sent down and then called back up, that is #3. On April 12th Elliott was called up to take the final non emergency call up.
Barrie and Sarich were hurt, and all of the non-emergency call ups were used up and the Avs didn't have any extra players. I get the sentiment that Roy should have rested people, but look at the scratch list on the 14th's game: Duchene, Barrie, Sarich, Mitchell, McLeod, and Varly... there was nobody else to play... everybody that was healthy had to play some minutes.
If people really want to harp on it, they should make more of an issue that the Avs didn't have a full roster at the trade deadline so that they could have called up some extra players for the final game.
No one is harping on the issue. This is like people saying the "sky is falling" when pointing out a team is playing poorly. It's not a big deal, it was just a small mistake.
Not having a full roster is a big part of the issue. Not bringing in a depth forward that could have been available is part of the issue. Roy chose not to do so for whatever reason, just like he chose not to call up players when guys might miss games earlier in the year.
It's only a problem, if it goes wrong and someone can't play and you have to dress 17 forwards in a back to back game, and then go with 16 because one gets injured in the game, or if a key D man gets hurt in a meaningless game. If those kinds of things don't happen, it's no harm no foul.
The 4 emergency call ups made things difficult but they didn't have to be. Sarich could have been on the IR, allowing for another forward or D man but he wasn't. He was never put on IR and listed as day to day, even though he hadn't played in forever, and they clearly had no plans of doing so with his back. They also traded for a 3rd string goalie they had to keep on the active roster instead of a forward that could have helped them.
These are all parts of the issue. Not a terrible mistake, just a little slip up that could have been prevented in hindsight. Roy may be god, but he's not infallible.
Edit: It looks like Sarich played some games after the trade deadline, so him being on the IR wouldn't have helped.