blahblah
Registered User
- Nov 24, 2005
- 21,327
- 972
Are folks aware that Hartnell is one of the very few wingers out there who makes more than Umberger who also scored less than Umberger this year? I'm assuming the only way we get Hartnell is for Umberger, or if Hartnell is bought-out.
I'm not terribly concerned about what occurred during a short season. I'm not saying to get him, but Harnell was also coming off a 37 goal season (one of two 30 goal seasons and 60 point seasons). Something that RJ hasn't even come close to, at least goal wise - a little closer point wise.
I mentioned that Hartnell is kind of either hit or miss. However during his career he's been far more consistent during his time on the ice that a guy like RJ has, including this season. Even though RJ scored a few more points, Hartnell had the same number of goals in quite a few less games. At least Hartnell was on pace for a 20 goal season during an off year.
I'm not saying to go for him, I'm just not no where near as dismissive of him as others around here. When I look at Hartnell, there are a few things I can say. He's pretty good 5 on 5, he can help our PP, he's been pretty decent in the past on the kill, he's a pretty durable top six player, and he's scored quite a few GWG's.
Hartnell can be a bit of an enigma, he is fully capable of scoring 35+ goals next season and probably 30+ into his middle 30's. He probably won't play to that level, as he's not nearly consistent enough. Maybe playing on a team like the Jackets of last season would be good for him. He is actually fully capable of playing top line minutes and producing.
At any rate, there is almost no chance we get him or even try and get him. However, I would have no issue getting him at that salary and term. Like you pointed out, even though I don't agree necessarily with how you came to that conclusion or how to solve the issue, RJ would probably need to be elsewhere. I would feel far more comfortable with Hartnell on the wing with Johasen than RJ.