Pavel even if the KHL went rogue which I kind of expect would like to compete in the World Championships and Olympic games, both would have been barred for him when a formal complaint was logged with the IIHF. So to say they had no teeth in enforcing this isn't really true either, even if he can play in Russia all he wants despite it being against the agreement it runs into huge problems in international play.
The problem is and it is probably less of a problem with their pay being so high in actual dollars, but this is bad for business if Malkin or Ovechkin follow suit. That contracts don't mean anything if you can go to the one league to make you whole. It is a huge let down for their partners and I am very disappointed the Wings didn't do what is in the best interest of the NHL. Same exact problem I had with a Devils owner who was trying to sell the team (eventually did) getting rid of a contract he thought could help him sell it despite it opening the door into what just played out to us.
The idea that they enforced this might hurt with future Marchenko negotiations I don't know. But there probably aren't a lot of people out there that would be worried about the vicious Wings known for reciprocating loyalty coming after their contract as long as they also plan on honoring it. As Winger pointed out the Krupp saga really crushed our ability and reputation with players league wide.
I mean what is the message of we let players quit on them and not honor their agreements. The country club and players call the shots actually runs even bigger in this idea. The mentality people hate Holland for or attribute to him just got a whole lot worse. That is at least as likely as the pitfalls you just lined out.
Players want to sign with good hockey teams. We are middle of the pack, our treatment of Datsyuk didn't factor into that. On the bigger picture it did reflect an important piece of business for the league moving forward and I think we let them down.
The Ilitch's wouldn't want a cash settlement. They would want him barred from violating the agreement. He could retire in actuality, sit out the year. That or as I said at the time actually put his money where his mouth was, sign for whatever Yekaterinburg could pay him and at least we would be having less of a debate.
The Wings did Datsyuk his solid, built all that good will and even managed to get out from under his contract. The Players leaguewide were so impressed that Stamkos wouldn't even meet with us... That worked out great.
This would have been more understandable. Though the idea that he didn't know the penalty existed first put out was pretty indefensible. But if he couldn't or wouldn't play hockey anymore what can you do. It would have been fine. I actually would have even been fine with him just sitting out a year to honor the KHL and NHL agreement. Finally relenting how special Pavel had been I would have been okay with him going straight to Yekaterinburg for the daughter reason. Turns out he did none of those, kind of like a lot of us said he wouldn't when this first broke.
But that was just my take on it. I understand those with such an attachment to Pavel that they don't want to look at him in any negative light.