Not really the same thing. While Callahan and Girardi are arguably our worst players at their position, they haven't been bad by any stretch. Morrow was a huge liability on the ice. I like rotating Dan in and out to keep him fresh, Cernak is prone to bad games here and there, as is Sergachev. Might be effective for a long playoff run.
Depends, I guess. This team is at the stage where no one is a flat out “liability.” But I would say Joseph brings more to the table than Callahan, and I echo his statement there. I’m worried coop will defer to experience come playoff time, and stick Callahan in situations where Joseph is more deserving. Remember him benching kuch in his second year here? Nearly killing bishop with playing time until he finally broke? Playing morrow in situations he didn’t belong? Until coop proves me otherwise, I’m nervous about his personnel decisions in the playoffs.
With that said, this season it seems that cooper has taken a step up. He learns something new seemingly every season, so hopefully this is the one where he outcoaches the coaches he will face in the playoffs.