The good ones get between 10 and 20 points AND are physical. Shawn Thornton's best season is 20 points. Most of the time when he did not reach 10 points it's because he played less than 70 games.
Tie Domi scored 15 goals and did 29 points while average 11 minutes of TOI in 2002-2003. 11 minutes is not really what i would call 3rd line TOI. He was 15th among forwards who played more than 10 games for the TOI. Only 2 forwards had less TOI than him.
Those players are extremely rare...Shawn Thornton is long passed being an effective player in the NHL and the league has changed since the time he was an effective 4th liner.
As for Tie Domi?...come on, you're quoting me numbers from 2002-2003.
Truth is, there are very few teams who employ guys who specialize in fighting AND can play hockey, teams mostly have guys like Brian Flynn on their 4th line these days.
Look i have nothing against Flynn but he is really nothing special. You can replace him easily. Honestly our view of a good 4th line player is skewed by all the crap and awful 4th lines we got the last 20 years. 10-15 points really is nothing special on a 4th line. It's what you should normally expect by such players. I personally think Flynn's defensive game is vastly overrated. He's been playing well lately but in the grand scheme of things it's a player we should look to replace by a more physical one in the upcoming years as far as i'm concerned.
Agreed that Brian Flynn is replaceable, I never argued that. I just responded to someone saying sarcastically that Brian Flynn's best seasons had him score 17pts and 13pts.
So I was curious, how much points did he think 4th liners typically accumulate?
Flynn's having a good year IMO, he's on pace for a career year. He's a pending UFA, he's likely playing out his final year here. He's fast, he's versatile, cheap and is low-maintenance.
I don't see what the issue is...agreed that he's a player the Habs will look to replace with a more physical one, but right now, I don't see anyone in the AHL who can do his job better. Not even McCarron.