Your Top 10 Red Wings Prospects

[MBH]

If they start the season eligible for the Calder, they are prospects.
Zadina, Rasmussen and Cholowski are ineligible. Lindstrom, Smith and Svech, I believe, are eligible.
Rank them, 1-10. You can rank more, but the top 10 will be used to rate the prospects.
(10 points for 1st, 1 point for 10th).

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Veleno
4. Berggren
5. Johansson
6. Niederbach
7. McIsaac
8. Svechnikov
9. Wallinder
10. Mastrosimone

Click to read more...

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Veleno
4. Johansson
5. Berggren
6. Niederbach
7. Wallinder
8. McIsaac
9. Mastrosimone
10. Viro

 

[Ed Ned and Leddy]

1a. Seider (RHD)
2a. Raymond (LW/RW)

3b. Veleno (C)
4b. Berggren (LW/RW)
5b. Johansson (LHD)

6c. Wallinder (LHD)
7c. Niederbach (C)
8c. McIsaac (LHD)
9c. Mastrosimone (LW/RW)
10c. Tuomisto (RHD)

HM: Elmer Soderblom, Emil Viro, Donovan Sebrango, Otto Kivenmaki, etc.

A-tier: surefire NHL potential, all-star upside (Zadina would fall here)
B-tier: likely NHL potential, top 6F top 4D upside (Rasmussen would fall here)
C-tier: possible NHL potential, mixed upside (Lindstrom/Svechnikov/Cholowski/G. Smith would fall here)

I see Veleno and Berggren as pretty interchangeable at this point, as is the entire C-tier.

 

[Christien]

1. Raymond
2. Seider
3. Berggren
4. Johansson
5. Niederbach
6. Veleno
7. Wallinder
8. Mastrosimone
9. Svechnikov
10. Tuomisto

 

[ricky0034]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Johansson
4. Veleno
5. Berggren
6. Niederbach
7. Mastrosimone
8. Wallinder
9. Kivenmaki
10. McIsaac
11. Soderblom

did 11 because it didn't feel right to leave off Soderblom with how close I have the bottom

some changes for me since October: Seider has proven himself just enough at this point for me to have him(narrowly) above Raymond on my list, I continue to be higher on Johansson over time and now have him(narrowly) above Veleno,McIsaac getting injured again is concerning and has caused me to drop him a few spots,Niederbach and Kivenmaki rose a bit

 

[Marky9er]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Berggren
4. Veleno
5. Johansson
6. Wallinder
7. Niederbach
8. Mastrosimone
9. McIsaac
10. Tuomisto

 

[Rzombo4 prez]

1. Raymond
2. Seider
3. Berggren
4. Johansson
5. Veleno
6. Niederbach
7. Mastrosimone
8. Wallinder
9. Petruzelli
10. Tuomisto

 

[lilidk]

Seider
Raymond
Veleno
Johansson
Mastersemone
Bergreen
Niederbach
Setkov
Wallinder
Smith
Petruzelli

 

[Retire91]

1a. Seider (RHD)
2a. Raymond (LW/RW)

3b. Veleno (C)
4b. Berggren (LW/RW)
5b. Johansson (LHD)

6c. Wallinder (LHD)
7c. Niederbach (C)
8c. McIsaac (LHD)
9c. Mastrosimone (LW/RW)
10c. Tuomisto (RHD)

HM: Elmer Soderblom, Emil Viro, Donovan Sebrango, Otto Kivenmaki, etc.

A-tier: surefire NHL potential, all-star upside (Zadina would fall here)
B-tier: likely NHL potential, top 6F top 4D upside (Rasmussen would fall here)
C-tier: possible NHL potential, mixed upside (Lindstrom/Svechnikov/Cholowski/G. Smith would fall here)

I see Veleno and Berggren as pretty interchangeable at this point, as is the entire C-tier.

I really like this although I put Raymond over Seider but not by much.

 

[Go Wings]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Johansson
4. Berggren
5. Veleno
6. Wallinder
7. Niederbach
8. McIsaac
9. Tuomisto
10. Mastrosimone

I put Johansson third because he continues to impress me with his developed. Wheres Berggren and Veleno have had bumps in their development Johansson has not.

 

[Ed Ned and Leddy]

I really like this although I put Raymond over Seider but not by much.

Thanks. The Seider/Raymond question is a good problem to have. At the moment, I feel more confident projecting Seider as a top pairing blueliner than I do projecting Raymond as a top line winger.

 

[Gniwder]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Johansson
4. Berggren
5. Veleno
6. Wallinder
7. Niederbach
8. McIsaac
9. Tuomisto
10. Mastrosimone

I put Johansson third because he continues to impress me with his developed. Wheres Berggren and Veleno have had bumps in their development Johansson has not.

I like this list the best in terms of probability of making the NHL based on what we've seen so far. I'd probably flip 8 & 9 because McIsaac has injury concerns.

Johansson is so underrated on this board.... I think he's got a batter shot than Berggren or Veleno.

 

[jaster]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Berggren
4. Veleno
5. Johansson
6. Niederbach
7. Wallinder
8. Mastrosimone
9. Svechnikov
10. Lindstrom

 

[The Zetterberg Era]

1.) Raymond
2.) Seider
3.) Johansson
4.) Berggren
5.) Veleno
6.) Wallinder
7.) Neiderbach (I think he winds up top 3 with graduates of a couple soon and how good he is.)
8.) Mastrosimone
9.) Tuomisto
10.) McIsaac (his health is really concerning at this point as is his missed development time. Hopefully he can rebound like Berggren)

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

I'm surprised I'm the only one here with Viro on his list at the moment. The kid's skating ability alone will make him a sure bet to at least be a #7 D-man in the NHL some day.

 

[Barry Amsterdam]

1-seider
2-raymond
3-berggren
4-veleno
5-johansson
6-neiderbach
7-wallinder
8-tuomisto
9-mcissac
10-Soderblom

 

[lhsgolf19]

If he keeps progressing I’ll be surprised if Petruzzelli isn’t in everyone’s Top 10 by the end of the year... Off to a great start, first 6 games 1.5 GAA .940 SV 1 SO

 

[Gniwder]

If he keeps progressing I’ll be surprised if Petruzzelli isn’t in everyone’s Top 10 by the end of the year... Off to a great start, first 6 games 1.5 GAA .940 SV 1 SO

Interesting point, he's also UFA unless the Wings sign him by August 31st. (4th year in college) I don't see any reason why he wouldn't sign with the Wings considering the goalie position is wide open when Greiss' contract ends in 2 years. He's not going to get a better opportunity anywhere else.

 

[Winger98]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Neiderbach
4. Veleno
5. Berggren
6. Johansson
7. Mastrosimone
8. Wallinder
9. Svechnikov
10. McIsaac

 

[Ghost of Ethan Hunt]

The Dirty Dozen (classic war movie reference). Also not counting Lindstrom as a prospect anymore as I expect he'll be FT NHL'er 3rd pairing this season (note his Euro recall). Cholo isn't a prospect anymore either but has further to go to re-reach the NHL than Lindstrom.

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Veleno
4. Berggren
5. Johansson
6. Niederbach
7. McIsaac
8. Wallinder
9. Tuomisto
10. Viro
11. Soderblom
12. Mastrosimone

 

[roman star]

wallinders the sleeper that could move right up after seider , unquestionable #1 , and raymond

 

[Vector Cereal]

Here's what I had as of October 15th (Subtracting Ras at 3):
1. Raymond
2. Seider
3. Berggren
4. Johansson
5. Veleno
6. Mastrosimone
7. McIsaac
8. Wallinder
9. Tuomisto
10. Lindstrom
11. Sebrango
12. Neiderbach
Here's what I had August 13th (Assumed Seider would graduate):
1. #4 pick
2. Berggren
3. Johansson
4. Veleno
5. #32 pick
6. McIsaac
7. Mastrosimone
8. Tuomisto
9. Smith
10. Barton

Glad I pushed my chips in on Berggren before the season started

 

[Fil Larkmanthanasiou]

1 Seider
2 Berggren
3 Raymond
4 Johansson
5 Veleno
6 Neiderbach
7 Wallinder
8 Mastrosimone
9 Svechnikov
10 Sebrango

 

[Hatter of the Beach]

Tier 1

1.Seider
2. Raymond

tier2
Berggren
Johansson
Wallinder
Niederbach
Veleno

tier 3
Tuomisto
Mastrosimone
Sebrango


HM: Elmer Solderblom, Keith Pettruzelli, Viro, McIssac

 

[William Rusco]

1. Seider
2. Raymond
3. Johansson
4. Neiderbach
5. Berggren
6. Lindstrom
7. Veleno
8. Wallinder
9. Svetchnikov
10. Smith