Hm, because points paint the whole picture, right? Having four points in 6 games as a rookie in his FIRST Stanley Cup playoffs is not bad, what the **** is wrong with some of you?
And do us all a favor: watch that series again, so you can see what we are talking about. Just because you are not scoring 5,000 points does not mean you play badly. They still were getting chances, and the Matthews line was so good that Trotz had to rematch his lines in order to prevent them from getting killed. This is what happened. You guys choose to ignore this. But then you'd have to admit you were wrong, I guess.
I'm bookmarking this comment, and because you always like to bring up Marner when discussing William, I will quote you if he has another slow start to the season and struggles for 20+ games. We'll see if you are gonna excuse his game or admit he should get paid adequately. Knowing this place, I'll go with the first option.
You are wrong, but I won't stop you from believing this.