Sure, but... Is it a good economic development?
I guess I'm not convinced this is the best way to spend public funds when the Wings are profitable on their own. That's the crux of the argument. Ilitch might be better than the other examples, but he's still cashing in on public money which will essentially help him add to his empire. The idea of Ilitch as a generous billionaire looking out for Detroit like an old Batman doesn't really strike me as congruent.
Ultimately, I don't feel stadium projects are the beacon to revitalization they are advertised. And that feeling strikes at the heart of the conversation, despite my enthusiasm for a new arena.
Depends in a city like Detroit, using state funds that are earmarked for big city development projects would seem ideal.
The idea that this would go to education, city streets, the police is ultimately misguided. That isn't what this fund is available for, it cannot happen. And boohoo that a bunch of corrupt Detroit politicians have been cut out of the process.
Very few people have a development of this magnitude to offer Detroit that applies to this fund. To buy up large tracks of land sometimes at poison pill rates to see the project through. Yes Ilitch is going to make money, but all of us know the exact area this arena is going in. Is that not good idea to strengthen the Woodward corridor and link Wayne State to the Entertainment district right on down to river?
Sure at times this doesn't make sense, but people are in my opinion pretty quick to judge a guy putting up likely in the neighborhood of 500 million dollars of his own wealth. They avoided tapping into money from Detroit because that was a non-starter for exactly the reason John Oliver's piece tried to make glancing blows at it.
Sure could we spend money on more socially acceptable principles? Yeah, um of course we don't live in a utopia though either and in the specific case of Detroit this makes a ton of sense and should not necessarily be examined in the same realm as the Miami Marlins or the Cincinnati stadium that took premium waterfront land.
Detroit is using an abandon area to connect two healthy areas and vacating waterfront property on their old site. Some of these are not the same and should not be analyzed in universal truths.
And like I said explain Indianapolis, Pittsburgh and Cleveland where entertainment districts have been vital in fixing broken and misused areas of cities.