Man the disrespect that Phaneuf and Ceci receive on these boards is criminal.
The suggestion of Claesson, Wideman or Chabot being better, I don't even know how to handle that.
heres the thing i am not expecting phaneuf or ceci to be game breakers, im not even expecting them to be worth near their cap hit
but is it really too much to ask for them to play a game with limited amount of mistakes. Every dman makes mistakes, but a dman tries to make up for it. Both of them make mistakes, then when they try to make up for it end up making more mistakes.
I am perfectly fine with having both of them in the lineup, im not on that side where we need to trade them for anything. I rather though we put more skill on our defence so we have a much better chance at getting a benefit from our defence then getting burned by it.
if chabot can play anywhere from 16-18 minutes (which is 4-6 minutes more than what our #6 dman has been averaging) and we scale back minutes from phaneuf and ceci(and separate them) it will reduce the brain farts and thus also reduce the complaints. Phaneuf and Ceci are good defenceman, we just need to reduce their brain farts because they arent game changers.
claesson-karlsson
phaneuf-chabot (rather have this pairing flip sides but the system)
oduya-ceci
and in a perfect world when boro comes back he replaces oduya because either boro has been a lot better this year or oduya has been that bad...im not sure