Ah, Frankie Beauchemin and Sammy Pahlsson; two guys I always wanted on the Flyers.
Before moving to San Diego, I worked about a mile from the Honda Center in Anaheim (no, I wasn't the guy in the Mickey Mouse outfit
) and had Ducks season seats. Frankie and Sammy were two of my favorite players on the team that won the Cup in 2007.
I don't recall a lot of debate, at the time, about Scott Niedermayer's Conn Smythe selection. He was the captain and played the most playoff minutes for Anaheim. The way he could control the pace of games, with his skating and puck handling, was remarkable. But you can certainly look back at those playoffs and make a case for several other guys. My list, in no particular order, would be Pronger, Giguere, Beauchemin, Getzlaf, Selanne and Pahlsson.
As mentioned above, while Niedermayer led the Ducks in playoff minutes, Beauchemin (who played one less game) was the top TOI/GP man. He could do it all. He led the team in even strength minutes, was second in short-handed minutes and was third among the Ducks defensemen in power play minutes (where he had four goals, second best on the team).
Even if Frankie wasn't the most valuable Duck in the playoffs, he was indispensable. I don't think the Ducks would have made it past the Wings in the conference finals without him. Sure, Anaheim had Niedermayer and Pronger on the back end, but they also had an aging Sean O'Donnell, Kent Huskins, Joe DiPenta and Ric Jackman. Without Beauchemin, and his 30 minutes a night, Anaheim would have been sunk.
Sammy and his line mates (Travis Moen and Rob Niedermayer) were just terrific matching up against some of their opponents best lines, shutting them down and providing some valuable "counter punch" offense. Sammy was the Ducks playoff leader in plus/minus (tied with Pronger), had two game winning goals, led his team in face-offs taken and was first in PK minutes. He was super valuable.
If Frankie or Sammy had won the Conn Smythe it probably would have been a surprise, but I would have had a big, stupid grin on my face.