Proposal: Noah Hanifin to New Jersey at the draft

[tarheelhockey]

Slavin = Hischier >>> Hanifin >>> Schneider

That's about right.

 

[Chan790]

Hischier definitely has more trade value than Noah Hanifin right now.

Not if you want to acquire Hanifin.

Hischier is the "take it or leave it" price.

 

[AfroThunder396]

I was thinking something more along the lines of Wood + Schneider for Hanafin.

 

[Stephen Gionta]

Hischier is worth more than any one player in the Canes organization.
Hall>Hischier>Slavin

 

[Zippy316]

Cory Schneider + Damon Severson for Noah Hanifin + Scott Darling

That's tough from a Devils perspective. I'm not sure if I want to take the chance on Darling.

I doubt the Canes want that though because I don't believe they need RD with Faulk/Pesce.

 

[tarheelhockey]

Hischier is worth more than any one player in the Canes organization.
Hall>Hischier>Slavin

Nope.

 

[CraigsList]

How can a defensmen having a disappointing sophmore and 3rd season be worth the 1st overall pick having an amazing all around season. I'm sorry but Hanifin is trending down if anything while Hischier is sky high. One is on the block while one is completely untouchable.

Hanifin is borderline on the block if he can get the Canes a top line center. Hischier has had a great year, but don’t use that against Hanifin. I feel that they’re of the same value.

 

[RodTheBawd]

Slavin = Hischier >>> Hanifin >>> Schneider

That's about right.

Slavin > Hischier >> Hanifin >>>> Schneider

 

[Finlandia WOAT]

. I'm sorry but Hanifin is trending down if anything ..... One is on the block while one is completely untouchable.

Hanifin isn't on the block, and he's not trending downward.

 

[Jared Dunn]

Not if you want to acquire Hanifin.

Hischier is the "take it or leave it" price.

Well obviously they're going to leave it then lol

 

[My3Sons]

Not if you want to acquire Hanifin.

Hischier is the "take it or leave it" price.

And if someone says yes then what?

 

[Chan790]

And if someone says yes then what?

Here? Nothing.

IRL? If Hanifin is traded to NJ, Hischier is definitely headed to Raleigh.

Well obviously they're going to leave it then lol

 

[135ace]

Hischier's value to the Devils is more than almost any player in the league. Teams just do not trade 1OA picks, especially a 1C who just had a great year. I really cannot imagine any realistic scenario where Nico is traded. In a vacuum I could see Slavin being close to Hischier in value, but I can guarantee you that if Carolina's GM calls Shero and offers Slavin for Nico straight up Shero is just hanging up the phone.
Really the only way Nico is moved is if Chia gets drunk and offers something like Drai++ for Nico.

 

[My3Sons]

Here? Nothing.

IRL? If Hanifin is traded to NJ, Hischier is definitely headed to Raleigh.

Wow, when did you get hired as the new puppet I mean GM in Raleigh? And when did the owner write that message for you and tell you to send it?

 

[Chan790]

Look, Canes fans didn't start this thread, but it's the same thing we tell everyone else:

We might make a deal from our strength on the blueline...but only for an elite, young top-line F.

We're not interested in packages, if anything we'll add to our side to get the guy we want because we have the system depth to do so. We don't need or want a Dman back...we have plenty of internal replacements.

It's pretty simple...if you're not offering an elite, young F in your proposal for one of our D...just don't bother.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

for Pavel Zacha, Damon Severson, John Quenneville, Blake Speers

Dude you're not even close, Carolina wants a young future #1 Centerman for Hanifin and you're not offering them one here.

 

[MartyOwns]

Uhhh, Hanifin and Hischier are of the same value.

yeah, maybe in a conversation between chiarelli and bergevin.

 

[SeidoN]

pass. those are three pretty reasonable pieces and Speers has shown good potential too.

and lol at Carolina wanting a 50 point player in his 18/19yr old season. Chiarelli aint GM here

 

[Stephen Gionta]

Would like it to be known, though Severson is 2 years older, points this season: Hanifin 32 in 79 games. 24 in 76 games. offensive potential seems similar

 

[Beezeral]

Need a few more spare parts from NJ to even this deal out

 

[One Winged Angel]

How can a defensmen having a disappointing sophmore and 3rd season be worth the 1st overall pick having an amazing all around season. I'm sorry but Hanifin is trending down if anything while Hischier is sky high. One is on the block while one is completely untouchable.

How did Noah Hanifin have a disappointing season?

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

I was thinking something more along the lines of Wood + Schneider for Hanafin.

And Carolina IS thinking something more along the lines of NO.

 

[Bobby Orr's Knees]

Uhhh, Hanifin and Hischier are of the same value. How nice that you’re more than willing to trade Schneider for him though!

Hanifin has loads of potential. But he is nowhere near Nico's trade value. Not even close. It's simply delusional to say that they are of the same value. And this is coming from a Flyers fan.

 

[Big McLargehuge]

I can see a scenario where Carolina trades Hanifin.

I can't see a scenario where Carolina trades him within the division at his age, not without getting back an absolutely stupid return at least. You don't get a young top 2/3 defenseman with #1 potential for a package of quantity.

Uhhh, Hanifin and Hischier are of the same value. How nice that you’re more than willing to trade Schneider for him though!

Hischier has more value in a vacuum.

 

[Bobby Orr's Knees]

Nope.

I think you are wrong on this one. I love Slavin. In my opinion, he is the most underrated D in the NHL. He doesn't get more hype because he plays in Carolina. I always thought that instead of Provorov vs. Werenski debate, it should have been Provorov vs. Slavin. Slavin's value to the organization would dictate that he could only be traded for a huge over-payment. Which is different from his league-wide trade value. Not a single GM in the league that would trade Hischier for him straight up right now. In two years things may change.