This team and coaching staff isn't underachieving. It's doing as well as it could have expected especially with the injuries.
I am very inclined to give Gorton a pass when this year was considered to be a proper full fledged retool transition year from the get go.
If Gorton wanted to "compete and retool" one foot in both boats then he would have made a trade to improve our troublesome center depth in the off season. That was the biggest hole we had.
The Stepan trade was a priority for Gorton before his NMC kicked in and with the trade for futures, it dictated that this team is no longer able of retooling while competing. Hard to trade for an upgrade on C and retool at the same time.
During the Shattenkirk negotiation, a lot of reports came out that Gorton wasn't interested in a Shattenkirk friendly deal that would weigh down the team in the future and wanted to focus on young players instead.
This year was always meant to be a bumpy ride from the start and this team was always meant to struggle to make the playoffs.
Gorton buckled himself in during the off season and made very few forced moves to improve the team so this upcoming summer would be easy to clear bodies, contracts, and restack the deck to his design.
The singular mistake that he made was leaving Vigneault at the helm. It's not the worst idea to keep the coach if you're in a retool year and waiting for the deadline, draft floor, and off season to blow it all up in a controlled fashion.
Average team, average coach, with no intention of buying at the deadline sounded okay except Vigneault's shelf life has far gone past expired and the rot has contaminated everything else in the organization. It's all seeping in and this team is now basically poisoned with lathargy, shame, and doubt.
I mean, the failure combination of Vigneault and Arniel that's learned nothing over the course of many playoff abominations hired Ruff based on familiarity and friendship without reflecting on what the needs of the team and coaching staff are. What can be expected out of a wholly dysfunction and unaccountable group of men who refused to admit their fault and learn from their mistakes?
I never expected this team to accomplish much this season but at least I hoped for victories and improvements within a losing effort. A step in the right direction for the team identity, team spirit, individual players, and coaxing out a few breakout players.
With Vigneault at the helm though, everything has deservingly gone to shit. We're trying to weather a storm and Vigneault decided to steer the ship into the only iceberg within travelling distance of the ship.