Well bruh, the draft hasn't produce good results either. That's the point. Why bash and defend the other? Because some guys from the draft found spots somewhere else?
You pimp a guy like Depuy who showed absolutely nothing yet bash AJH who, at the very least, showed he could be a valuable super sub for botj club and country. It makes no sense.
The problem is that IMFC has trouble developping and incorporating young players into the first team. The "source" (draft vs Academy) isn't the problem here. I expect Garde, a provem developper, to fix the issue.
Because for the very little amount of signed players from drafts vs large amount of signed players from the academy I already see a big difference. For every Bill Hamid there are 8 Lefevres. And it's not only for Montreal but for every team in this league in 2017. Larin, Zimmerman, Rowe, Dwyer, Hairston, Danladi, Gressel, Harrison, Blake, Roldan, Sjoberg, Parker, Bono are all upcoming stars and guess where they come from?(and that's just a third) vs Fagundez, Morris, Zardes who come from academies, see the difference? If you don't let me just tell you that they're all one-season wonders thus far and are not very strong mentally. I'm not saying that players from the draft are absolute gems but the day Academies will produce as many quality players I'll have more faith in them. The only success from Academies all throughout the league is Bill Hamid, Yedlin, Will Trapp and Acosta. Adams and Ballou potentially. Personally, I think academies are just there to show off that we're developping our own players too. Little do you know that the NCAA program is by far more competitive than whatever local leagues Academies play in. They spend a lot of money on it.
As for Depuy, I am not his promoter but I think looking at Fisher for example in which he had troubles in his first year, played a few games in USL to then vastly improved in his second, I'm just using the same algorithm. I am not bashing AJH, I'm saying he could be a one-season wonder, just like how I said I don't think Drogba wouldn't replicate his 2015 success in 2016 or how Mancosu can't be a number one forward because of a few good games games in 2016. I doubt Garde will like his style too. He has no tactical IQ. Let's wait and find out.