Value of: Miller + to EDM for Oilers 2018 1st pick [unconditional]

[PenguinSpeed]

Penguins offer

Miller- Rangers, Pens 1st Round Pick Plus Daniel Sprong

Pens want another Center for depth, Rangers want picks and Young talent to rebuild.

 

[Igor Shestyorkin]

Would you trade a chance at Dahlin for a 50 point forward?

Since Miller frankly isn't that great, yes.

 

[Fatty McLardy]

Guaranty you haven't seen him play one second in the playoffs.

Saw him enough actually, maybe not every minute of those 41 games but enough to know that he just doesn't take his game to a level required to be successful in the playoffs..

 

[ManofSteel55]

If GM's want players, why would NYR be packaging Miller with a question mark first which will likely be a lottery pick as well as NYR seems to be open to a rebuild. They could just trade Miller for a 1st at the TDL and have an extra pick instead of combining 2 assets for one first

Are you seriously not understanding what I am saying here? Do you think a GM would prefer a pick in this years draft or a similar one in a draft two years out? 10/10 times it will be this years draft because they will have scouted the players, and whoever they draft is more likely to make an impact sooner.

 

[Bounces R Way]

Don't see any way the Oilers trade their 2019 1st without an experienced top pairing dman coming back. Maybe if you're nice they'll send over their lucky nude photo of Bettman with it.

 

[bernmeister]

Penguins offer

Miller- Rangers, Pens 1st Round Pick Plus Daniel Sprong

Pens want another Center for depth, Rangers want picks and Young talent to rebuild.

not enuf potential upside - a late 1st + a boom/bust W
nope

 

[member 105785]

Are you seriously not understanding what I am saying here? Do you think a GM would prefer a pick in this years draft or a similar one in a draft two years out? 10/10 times it will be this years draft because they will have scouted the players, and whoever they draft is more likely to make an impact sooner.

I understand, but it's not worth a 50 point player as an add to move a year ahead

 

[Seachd]

Horrible for NY LOL

Rangers can realistically finish behind Edmonton. Why are they giving up Miller for potentially worse pick ahahahahha

Doesn't look like you read the proposal.

 

[HawkeyTalkMan]

Lol wait two years for our first round pick where it's hopefully a bottom 15 pick again and take a middle six winger for your likely top 5 pick and crack at Dahlin

Classic bern