Jesus.
We are still doing this stuff?
One of the Leafs goaltenders has played like a #1.
The other looks like he'd struggle to stop a beach ball from 100 feet away.
The Reimer vs Bernier debate was a debate at the beginning of the year.
It's no longer a debate. One guy has outplayed the other and has earned the role.
I agree that Reimer is our starter until he messes up badly or gets trade.
But I wouldn't count Bernier out either. He's going to do a hell of a lot better going forward than he has been so far this season.
In his last ten starts, he played great in 6 of them, was mediocre in two (but still won one), and got blown out in two (and wasn't even bad in SJ until we had clearly lost). Given the way the Leafs have been playing lately, that's about as good as you can hope for, even from a pretty good goaltender.