I really don't think we will be able to keep him now with Marleau on the books. I think that's fine. Marleau can play in all situations, is versatile and brings leadership. Yes it's an overpayment but at least he brings value in multiple areas. JVR needs to be sheltered in 5v5 to be effective. Yes he is a loss on the powerplay but we have other weapons. If Matthews gets more icetime and finds his niche on the powerplay that can replace a lot of that production.
I think that long term we have Matthews, Marner and Nylander who can all drive a line and will be making big bucks. Then we have Kadri who seems to be a perfect fit beside Marner at 4.5m. We also have a few cheap support players in Hyman, Brown and Kapanen to support the forward core plus others on the way.
Yes our depth is going to be trimmed but when our big 3 are in their prime they won't need quite as much support to win.
Long term:
Hyman - Matthews
Kadri - Marner
Nylander - Kapanen
Throw in Johnsson, Grundstrom and others and someone in that mix is going to exceed expectations and be more than your run of the mill top 9.
Plus our d-core is likely going to be built more on depth and not have one guy eating 10m cap so there will be some money for scoring wingers down the road just for someone who brings more than JVR.
I do think we have a cup window in the next few years with the big 3 on the cheap, but there is a window far beyond that as well. I expect our big 3 to keep getting better. Same goes for Rielly. Liljegren is an X factor. Could disappoint but could just as easily blow expectations out of the water.
We don't need JVR.