Value of: Jacob Trouba's rights

[Daximus]

How bout a Kadri + Gardiner (extended 5x5.75) for Trouba + Roslovic?
Kadri is a top 6 center with 2 30+goal seasons playing some of the toughest minutes.

I'd be really tempted to do Kadri for Trouba straight up. I just dread giving you guys a top pairing of Reilly - Trouba.

 

[Snowman]

How bout a Kadri + Gardiner (extended 5x5.75) for Trouba + Roslovic?
Kadri is a top 6 center with 2 30+goal seasons playing some of the toughest minutes.

I wouldn't do this because I don't think Kadri would work well with Laine and Ehlers. Plus there would be zero chance of throwing in Roslovic to get Gardiner.

 

[Maukkis]

Devon Toews, Brock Nelson and a lottery protected 1st.

The only thing missing is any kind of incentive for the Jets to bite. You're basically offering us nothing.

How bout a Kadri + Gardiner (extended 5x5.75) for Trouba + Roslovic?
Kadri is a top 6 center with 2 30+goal seasons playing some of the toughest minutes.

Matthews.

 

[Jeti]

Another player doesn’t want to stay in Winnipeg. They are a dam good team, I hope they can convince him to stay.

Another? Who are all these other players who want out in your mind?

 

[Hunter368]

How bout a Kadri + Gardiner (extended 5x5.75) for Trouba + Roslovic?
Kadri is a top 6 center with 2 30+goal seasons playing some of the toughest minutes.

Good offer but no I wouldn't do that.

 

[Freudian]

Right now you'd be trading for the pleasure of an arbitration hearing unless the player signs with you before then. I can't see any team doing that unless they are allowed to negotiate an extension beforehand.

 

[Daximus]

Right now you'd be trading for the pleasure of an arbitration hearing unless the player signs with you before then. I can't see any team doing that unless they are allowed to negotiate an extension beforehand.

That is likely how any trade with Trouba would be handled.

 

[Bedards Dad]

Matthews.

Are you adding in Scheifele?

 

[Walt22]

Are you adding in Scheifele?

Why would we offer two of the best players in the deal?

 

[Advanced stats]

To fellow leafs fans:

I'd love trouba as much as the next guy. He's the perfect solution to any remaining problems we have. It's a perfect match.

Trouble is, if Trouba is hesitant to sign in winnipeg, he likely has the same hesitations about Toronto. Cold? Canada? Fans? Wants to play in America?
I don't know if it's worth the risk to trade for Trouba if he won't be happy playing in Toronto.
We could throw together an attractive package though if he was willing to sign long term around 6 million.
Trade Gardiner for 1st + 2nd.
Trade 1st +1st + prospect for Trouba.

Rielly- Trouba
Dermott- Hainsey
Carrick - Zaitzev

 

[Gabe Kupari]

To fellow leafs fans:

I'd love trouba as much as the next guy. He's the perfect solution to any remaining problems we have. It's a perfect match.

Trouble is, if Trouba is hesitant to sign in winnipeg, he likely has the same hesitations about Toronto. Cold? Canada? Fans? Wants to play in America?
I don't know if it's worth the risk to trade for Trouba if he won't be happy playing in Toronto.
We could throw together an attractive package though if he was willing to sign long term around 6 million.

Why wouldn't he sign in WPG for 6 then? This whole thread is pre-mature

 

[Advanced stats]

Why wouldn't he sign in WPG for 6 then? This whole thread is pre-mature

Because for some unknown reason he seems to have hesitations about Winnipeg.
Maybe playing with Matthews is more appealing to him. Idk

 

[Hunter368]

To fellow leafs fans:

I'd love trouba as much as the next guy. He's the perfect solution to any remaining problems we have. It's a perfect match.

Trouble is, if Trouba is hesitant to sign in winnipeg, he likely has the same hesitations about Toronto. Cold? Canada? Fans? Wants to play in America?
I don't know if it's worth the risk to trade for Trouba if he won't be happy playing in Toronto.
We could throw together an attractive package though if he was willing to sign long term around 6 million.
Trade Gardiner for 1st + 2nd.
Trade 1st +1st + prospect for Trouba.

Rielly- Trouba
Dermott- Hainsey
Carrick - Zaitzev

UFA #3D, late 1st and late 2nd......that offer would be beat others with ease.

 

[Liferleafer]

Why wouldn't he sign in WPG for 6 then? This whole thread is pre-mature

Listen, if we have to endure Matthews/Nylander offersheet threads....then you have to deal with this one.

 

[ottawa]

UFA rights are worth nothing but RFA rights still let you control the player. At that point though a sign and trade just seems more streamlined.

If it's to easy to control an Rfa, why hasn't he signed yet?

Rights aren't worth much, there's no guarantee he signs with the trading team. And then there's an 8m price tag which diminishes his value.

 

[Advanced stats]

UFA #3D, late 1st and late 2nd......that offer would be beat others with ease.

..... except that wasn't the offer.
Go back and actually read it. 1st + 1st + prospect. That would beat most teams best offer for an unsigned #2 defenseman

 

[The Magic Man]

Gardiner
1 of: Kapanen/Johnsson/Brown
2nd

Or Gardiner & Liljegren with a small add our way.

 

[Maukkis]

Gardiner
1 of: Kapanen/Johnsson/Brown
2nd

Or Gardiner & Liljegren with a small add our way.

A load of shit for the Jets. Start with something meaningful.

 

[Hunter368]

..... except that wasn't the offer.
Go back and actually read it. 1st + 1st + prospect. That would beat most teams best offer for an unsigned #2 defenseman

Jets don’t need magic beans for Trouba....trading Trouba for beans would be a huge lose. Easy pass due to poor fit

 

[Maukkis]

To fellow leafs fans:

I'd love trouba as much as the next guy. He's the perfect solution to any remaining problems we have. It's a perfect match.

Trouble is, if Trouba is hesitant to sign in winnipeg, he likely has the same hesitations about Toronto. Cold? Canada? Fans? Wants to play in America?
I don't know if it's worth the risk to trade for Trouba if he won't be happy playing in Toronto.
We could throw together an attractive package though if he was willing to sign long term around 6 million.
Trade Gardiner for 1st + 2nd.
Trade 1st +1st + prospect for Trouba.

Rielly- Trouba
Dermott- Hainsey
Carrick - Zaitzev

6 AAV long term for Trouba means that he's staying put. Also, that package is godawful for a contender.

 

[Hunter368]

Gardiner
1 of: Kapanen/Johnsson/Brown
2nd

Or Gardiner & Liljegren with a small add our way.

1) Your offering at best a 3rd liner or a 3rd liner prospect and a late 2nd? So your trying to be insulting? Horrible offer

2) Gardiner is a #3 D ufa and Liljegren is ok a prospect. Pass

 

[Advanced stats]

6 AAV long term for Trouba means that he's staying put. Also, that package is godawful for a contender.

Except maybe he doesn't want to stay in Winnipeg.

 

[Advanced stats]

Jets don’t need magic beans for Trouba....trading Trouba for beans would be a huge lose. Easy pass due to poor fit

Value is value either way. As I've said, a 1st + 1st + prospect (Bracco?) Is likely your best package.
Nothing says you can't flip the firsts for someone who'd fill our your defense. Someone willing to stay in the peg.

 

[Hunter368]

Value is value either way. As I've said, a 1st + 1st + prospect (Bracco?) Is likely your best package.
Nothing says you can't flip the firsts for someone who'd fill our your defense. Someone willing to stay in the peg.

No value isn’t value to a cup contender. That wouldn’t even be considered a serious offer.

 

[Advanced stats]

No value isn’t value to a cup contender. That wouldn’t even be considered a serious offer.

It would honestly be the best offer. What if you took those 2 1st added a piece and got Karlsson. You have the cap space to work resign him. I maintain that value is value, it just has to be spent properly.

Your saying even if the "other return" you got for Trouba was less value, but included roster players, you'd take that over Torontos package because Toronto's is just picks and prospects?