I don't disagree with that, but when you have players on the roster like Derek Ryan and Nordstrom playing 15 minutes a game no matter how spectacularly ineffective they are, it's a valid criticism. Tolchinsky has played 4 games in the NHL and has 2 points (in pretty limited icetime). Nordstrom has played 70 games this year and has 6. If you give Tolchinsky the ice time Nordstrom has gotten, he gets somewhere in the neighborhood of 35 points. That's not a small difference.
I disagree. He's got a career high of 36 points in the AHL. 2 NHL points in 4 garbage games at the end of the season isn't enough of a sample size to assume he'll have sustained success for a season. If he was tearing it up in the AHL, that would be one thing, but he's not. The season when Ryan and Tolchinsky were on the Checkers together, Ryan had 23G, 55P and was a +5 in 70 games. Tolchinsky had 14G, 36P and was a -16 in 72 games. The following season, Ryan had 5G, 13P and was a +4 in only 9 games, Tolchinsky had 7 goals, 23p and was a -10 in 59 games. There's absolutely no valid reason to say Sergey deserves to be playing over Derek Ryan. Maybe he'll put it together and become an excellent NHL player down the road, but he's done nothing to say he deserves it right now.
You have guys like Zykov and Foegele who are clearly far better NHLers than a good chunk of the roster, and it's three games and a fare-thee-well. If I'm a guy toiling away in the AHL and who has had modest success in the few games I've gotten in the NHL, and I see guys like that continuing to take a job from me, I'd be ****ing pissed.
This was Foegele's first season in the AHL and he got a callup, was ecstatic, did well, but went back to Charlotte so that he could help them in the playoff run. Zykov didn't show he was legit until this season in the AHL. He's getting a string of games now to show what he can do at the NHL level, but will likely go back to help the Checkers as well in the not too distant future.
IMO, both guys will get every chance to make the team next year.