I don't think that is the case at all. They went from worst in the league to giving the best regular season team in the east (Caps) a huge run for their money last year as an 8th seed. Just making the playoffs last year was a huge win for them and nobody expected it to start the season. This year, it sucked, but they got a crappy draw playing a team that was the 2nd best team in the east, lost their 2C for 3 games and still gave the Bruins all they could handle.
If this was a situation where they were a mature team that was playing inferior opponents and continuously losing (like the Caps), then maybe it would come into play, but this is young team that has made huge strides in 2 years and lost to teams that should have beat them in the playoffs.
Yeah, I don't think they're down on him at all. He's in charge of the Marlies, and they're looking pretty fantastic at the moment. It's just that only one guy can get the job. Like Dundon said, there are only 31 of these jobs, and as of right now, only three look like they're turning over this off-season. That means most of the guys on long list of potentials (Lombardi, Fenton, BriseBois, Fitzgerald, Dubas, Hunter, Futa, Guerin, Zito, McCrimmon, Gilman, Greeley, etc.) are still going to be waiting their turn when the draft rolls around. They can't *all* get the Seattle job, either (or Detroit, if Holland leaves to run the Kraken).
Like Hank said, I think we're OK if we remove the "interim" from Waddell's title. He's not that bad, and he's probably learned a bit in his time away from the hot seat. And I like Dudley. But one of the things that Dundon's "hive-mind" plan has going for it is that you're always able to add another like-minded person to the mix. If Dubas gets passed over in Toronto, I wouldn't be surprised if we make a run at him. He's the kind of guy Dundon said he'd be willing to pay for.
Some of these guys are going to be returning Dundon's calls saying "tell me more about the model you were thinking about" once the music stops in Toronto and Minnesota and there's only one chair left. Call me a dick, but I can't wait to hear that Mike Futa reached out to us after he didn't even get a call from either Toronto or Minnesota, and the Kings "playoff run" lasted exactly four games.