Proposal: Boston /Calgary

[Sparky93]

The most tiresome excuse it never ends. If you have every watched pasta play he could carry any line in hockey. It doesn’t matter who he plays with he would produce no matter what. He’s value is significantly higher compared to MT

I guess we'll see in a couple years

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Also MT wouldn’t land you either of those two I’m not knocking him at all. Also pasta over the last 4 years is 3 in points of all rw.

Tkachuk is definitely worth more than McAvoy. They were in the same draft and every redraft still puts Tkachuk ahead of McAvoy for a reason

 

[Volica]

Gross.
Can we interest Boston in a Pasta for Bennett and other shite package?

 

[DJJones]

That package of assets will get you a pretty good veteran 2nd liner as a rental

 

[bruins4thecup65]

Tough crowd lol

 

[thesensguy]

Tkachuk is definitely worth more than McAvoy. They were in the same draft and every redraft still puts Tkachuk ahead of McAvoy for a reason

McAvoy is a #1 RD. I am a huge Tkatchuk fan, but no way I’d take Tkatchuk over McAvoy.

 

[Horton Hears A Woo]

Tkachuk is definitely worth more than McAvoy. They were in the same draft and every redraft still puts Tkachuk ahead of McAvoy for a reason

In no universe is MT worth more than CM. Damn man. And who does those re draft? Not gm in the league I’m almost positive anyone would rather have a young franchise d man over a very good winger.

 

[DFF]

To Boston : Mathew Tkachuk
To Calgary: 1rst round pick, Vaakanen and Jake Debrusk

To Boston: 1st, Bennett, valaimaki
To Calgary: Pasta

 

[Scruffy]

That offer may get you a Signed Keith Tkachuk puck and jersey

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

In no universe is MT worth more than CM. Damn man. And who does those re draft? Not gm in the league I’m almost positive anyone would rather have a young franchise d man over a very good winger.

Franchise d man? Young very good winger? Man your homer glasses are massive. Go link me 1 redraft (not reated by you on CapFriendly) where McAvoy is ahead of Tkachuk, I'll wait.

 

[Hookslide]

To Boston: 1st, Bennett, valaimaki
To Calgary: Pasta

Pasta stays in Boston ........peanut butter and jelly sandwich does not equal Pasta

 

[Horton Hears A Woo]

Franchise d man? Young very good winger? Man your homer glasses are massive. Go link me 1 redraft (not reated by you on CapFriendly) where McAvoy is ahead of Tkachuk, I'll wait.

Bro your coming off on the wrong side here. CM is considered one of the best young d man in the game. It’s not homer it’s just facts So idk why your being aggressive. Like I said I would be shocked if any GM in the league that would take MT over CM. Maybe homer and mirror for you?

 

[burstnbloom]

Franchise d man? Young very good winger? Man your homer glasses are massive. Go link me 1 redraft (not reated by you on CapFriendly) where McAvoy is ahead of Tkachuk, I'll wait.

There is a compelling statistical argument that McAvoy is the best defender in Hockey this year. He's 23 years old, right handed and makes under $5m this year and next. He's one of the most valuable assets in the NHL. You don't have to agree with that, but you'd be wrong. I love Matt Tkachuk. Love. I would overpay for him. Never in a million years would I give up a 23 yo #1D for a wing. Never.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Bro your coming off on the wrong side here. CM is considered one of the best young d man in the game. It’s not homer it’s just facts So idk why your being aggressive. Like I said I would be shocked if any GM in the league that would take MT over CM. Maybe homer and mirror for you?

Theres no question McAvoy is a great dman, probably top 20. But you are acting like Tkachuk is just your average middle 6 winger when he is a top 10 left wing in the league and likely a future captain.

 

[Mantis]

This is the same guy who proposed Kuraly and Wagner for Conor Garland on the Bruins board.

 

[TooMuchMan]

This is plain ol' ridiculous. Tkachuk is worth well more than what the op is offering... he's one of the best young wingers in this game and all but untouchable from a CGY perspective, I'd imagine...

As for the McAvoy and Pasta counterproposals, they're good for a laugh (which I'd imagine is their intent). Pasta arguably has the most valuable contract in the league... and McAvoy is rightly one of the defensemen in the Norris discussion, so i think that any non-chuckle related offers are probably far and away not going to get a sniff from Bruins' fans.

 

[The don godfather]

Shut this down before it created a world war. McAvoy for a bag of pucks come on.

 

[McJedi]

What more would it take?

2022 1st, 2023 1st, Vaakanen, Studnicka and DeBrusk.

Aka. A lot.

 

[Double Dion]

I mean the only guys I'd consider it for are untouchable in Boston. I'd move Monahan, Gaudreau or Giordano for less than market value. But if you want Tkachuk or Lindholm I would want every bit of value out of those two players. They are guys a good team gets and then wins a cup with. Monahan and Gaudreau are good offensive players, but I don't think they really move the needle in terms of winning and Giordano is just old. Tkachuk and Lindholm are also signed to good value (Tkachuk) and exception value (Lindholm) contracts.

 

[Horton Hears A Woo]

2022 1st, 2023 1st, Vaakanen, Studnicka and DeBrusk.

Aka. A lot.

Man I’m a bruins fan and I would do that all day not going to lie. I absolutely love MT

 

[Horton Hears A Woo]

Theres no question McAvoy is a great dman, probably top 20. But you are acting like Tkachuk is just your average middle 6 winger when he is a top 10 left wing in the league and likely a future captain.

I never said a single bad thing about MT once. I absolutely love him and wish he was on the bruins. But he doesn’t hold the same value as pasta or Mac that’s all I said

 

[Hookslide]

2022 1st, 2023 1st, Vaakanen, Studnicka and DeBrusk.

Aka. A lot.

Absolutely one of the dumbest proposals I have ever seen posted..........

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

I never said a single bad thing about MT once. I absolutely love him and wish he was on the bruins. But he doesn’t hold the same value as pasta or Mac that’s all I said

I understand Pasta. I was never debating that

I also understand team needs factor in. I get not wanting to move McAvoy, a #1 for a winger that wouldn't even be on your 1st line. Its kinda the opposite in Calgary though. Flames dobt need RD where they do need Tkachuk. I wouldn't trade Tkachuk 1 for 1 for McAvoy. Saying Mac has more value is fundamentally flawed imo because their values are probably pretty close but like I said earlier Tkachuk still goes before him in every redraft

 

[Horton Hears A Woo]

Absolutely one of the dumbest proposals I have ever seen posted..........

On who’s end? Because I need an answer to this

 

[Sparky93]

To Boston : Mathew Tkachuk
To Calgary: 1rst round pick, Vaakanen and Jake Debrusk

If you make that a 2022 1st, I think thats pretty close to Gaudreau. Definitely not Tkachuk though.