The NHL isn’t going to Cincinnati anytime soon/ever, too many hurdles.
It’ll be Atlanta and Utah. After that it’ll be a bit before it expands again.
Atlanta is a two time NHL loser. I've heard every excuse in the book as to why, but the fact remains that the league has failed twice there. The third time wouldn't necessarily be a charm.
In 1978, the WHA came within one vote of being merged with the NHL. The Cincinnati Stingers would have joined the NHL. The next year, the NHL voted to take the WHA but the Stingers opted out and took a payment to fold. Point is that Cincinnati was considered an NHL city 40 years ago. The Stingers probably would have met the same fate as the Harford Whalers-relocation after a decade or so-had they ended up in the NHL.
A new arena with some well-heeled ownership and it could work out. I agree that it's a long shot, but the ECHL Cincinnati Cyclones are regularly drawing 8,000 or more on weekend dates with virtually no media coverage. The Cyclones only report how many people are actually in the building compared to the nebulous "tickets distributed" method of attendance reporting that most teams (including the CBJ) use. The television market is about the same size as Columbus and Salt Lake City. Cincinnati comes into play when the NHL goes to 36 teams and/or Arizona, Winnipeg and Florida start looking for new locations.
Jacksonville FL could be a darkhorse candidate for NHL expansion at some point. It's a growing market and if reported attendance figures are to be believed, the ECHL Icemen draw quite well.