I don't want to rain on the Wahlstrom parade, but IIRC
@Magua says Farabee is the better USNTDP winger.
I missed my summons from yesterday.
I've probably watched ~10/19 of the USDP's USHL games this year. I feel like I have a good read on every player up and down the lineup (if there was someone else you were curious about). I do think
Joel Farabee (LW) is -- as you said I said! -- holistically the best draft eligible on that team. Kid just understands how to hockey and is so well-rounded. He's stockier than Farabee, but I get some Parise-ish vibes from him. Most noticeable things about Farabee are that he thinks the game at such a high end level all over the ice and he works his ass off relentlessly, though he's not a pest or anything. Counted on at all strengths. He's a legit 5'11, and he needs a lot more weight gain at 160 and change. Yet, he wins far more battles than he should at that weight. Whenever he goes after a loose puck or has a guy draped on him, he always finds a way to come out with pucks. It's an uncanny skill. But he's not just motoring out there; he's got soft hands and good vision and reads plays so fast. Definitely has a poise to him. Kid knows how to create and manipulate space on/off puck with the best of 'em.
But I’m not sure I'd call him my idea of a quintessential top 10 pick either (even if I would sneak him in for my rankings). I'd feel more comfortable taking him in the 11-15 range. But I don't expect he goes top 10. In our case with the Blues pick, since we
can't pick top 10 and trade ups don't happen, he should be a prime target. If I know anything about how the Flyers scout -- and I do -- I have to believe he would/should be on their radar. He checks off basically everything they value, including seeming like a high character kid.
But it’s more his skating than anything else that is holding him back for me from a higher tier. The skating is a little unclean without high end burst or top end speed, sometimes looks a little wobbly. It's fine, no need to exaggerate it as close to a negative. But for his size, you just wish there was a
littttttle more there for a high pick. That said, I feel reasonably comfortable projecting growth there. He's got a lot of muscle to gain yet, his mechanics are mostly fine -- just a little clean up work and power skating and physical development might correct any issues. And if he does improve it, watch out, because it's the only hang-up.
Then you have
Oliver Wahlstrom (RW), who continues to irk me. Always the same reasons. Comparing Farabee and Wahlstrom is a case study in more and less than the sum of one's parts. We won’t have the chance to draft Wahlstrom though, as he's a top 10 lock. It's a case where I try to like him more and can't, though I don't dislike him either. Now,
he looks like the picture of a dynamic top 10 pick, top 5 even. I get why people covet him. His raw tools and ability might be the best of any forward not named Svechnikov -- and of course he's a shooter putting up great numbers. And he's 3 inches taller, heavier, and a better skater (though more good than great) than Zadina. And he's a little more dynamic than Brady Tkachuk. If he played with the hunger and smarts of any of those guys, he could be the second best forward, but he doesn't.
He’s inconsistent and has a slightly lazy quality that grates on me. He’ll battle physically for pucks if he has to and is strong when he does, but he constantly seems disengaged and floating. His play speed can feel a tad slow on the puck too. I ripped Tippett a new bum-hole last year, who has a similar toolsy scorer's skill-set, but Wahlstrom isn’t brain dead like him and doesn't have tunnel vision near to that degree (does a bit though, like most pure shooters). But if he doesn't have the puck and isn't scoring, I’m not really sure what he’s always contributing. I'm not sold he processes things at anything above an average level. He makes unnecessary overly difficult 1-on-1 moves on routine plays. Oliver refuses to pass up a fancy deke opportunity, even in weird spots.....it gets old since he fails at it too much for my liking, though paired with Jack Hughes the last couple months he's lessened it. Tbh I think he overrates his own ability. To the Jack Hughes mention, Wahlstrom has been attached to his hip since his call-up. Farabee spent some time on their LW, but has been centered with Wise of late (Caufield at wing). Hughes is an absolute magician and the next Keller and does what feels like most of the work for Oliver now. I never get/got the impression he dominates his shifts; now it feels like Hughes dominates for him, and he is along for the ride with his scorer's touch.