Henkka
Registered User
If we finish 6th, the combined odds for 7th to 15th to win a TOP3 pick is 99.7%.
So, in most probable cases, one team from the 7-15 group will will get a TOP3 pick. That will drop the 6th team to 7th, if they don't win the TOP3 pick by themselves.
So if you are 6th worst:
7.5% chance for 1st overall
23.3% chance for TOP3 pick
~77% chance to drop 1 position
So far the current system history has been:
- Toronto was league-last at 2016, did win 1st overall, with 20% probablility. There was 80% chance not to win, so they got lucky and got Matthews.
- Winnipeg was 6th worst at 2016, did win the 2nd overall, with 7.8% probability. There was combined 84.7% chance not to win a TOP2 pick, so they got lucky and got Patrik Laine.
- Columbus was 4th last and did win the 3rd overall, passing 2 teams, EDM and VAN, from the standings position. Proability for a TOP3 pick was 29%.
I could think this was almost meaningless win for the CBJ in big picture, EDM would still have taken Puljujärvi and VAN a defenceman Juolevi. CBJ would have got their Dubois at 5th or 4th or 6th. Remember Jarmo trying to trade down knowing the situation, but no one was interested. He "hated" to pick Dubois that early, but there was a huge organizational need for a center after a Johansen-trade. I'm quite sure everybody at 3-7 got their favourable player.
At 2017 the percentage for 1st overall was lowered to 18% for the league-worst team (COL).
- New Jersey did win the 1st overall, with 8.5% probability. They were 5th worst at regular season. There was 91.5% chance not to win a 1st overall.
- Philadelphia did win the 2nd overall, with 2.4% probability. They were 13th worst at regular season. There was 95.4% chance not to win a TOP2 pick for Philadelphia
- Dallas did win the 3rd overall, with 6.4% probability. They were 8th worst at regular season. There was 81.0% probability not to win a TOP3 pick for Dallas.
So far...
League-Worst
4th worst
5th worst
6th worst
8th worst
13th worst
...have won the TOP3 pick. It's really a crapshoot. Especially that 2017 lottery was almost meaningless for teams positioned at 1-7, because there wasn't a huge talent drop at TOP3, like 2016 had it after TOP2 picks.
As for 2018, Dahlin is a real difference-maker like Matthews or Laine, but after that I think all teams from 2nd to 7th overall will get one of their favourable players.
If I combine the 2016-2017-2018 drafts:
1. Dahlin
2. Matthews
3. Laine
---------- talent drop
Hischier,Patrick, Keller, Dubois, Zadina, A.Svechnikov, M.Tkachuk, B.Tkachuk etc.
Juolevi, Heiskanen, Makar, Boqvist, Hughes, Bouchard etc.
If we don't win the lottery, I think it doesn't matter much if we are 2nd or 7th.
So, in most probable cases, one team from the 7-15 group will will get a TOP3 pick. That will drop the 6th team to 7th, if they don't win the TOP3 pick by themselves.
So if you are 6th worst:
7.5% chance for 1st overall
23.3% chance for TOP3 pick
~77% chance to drop 1 position
So far the current system history has been:
- Toronto was league-last at 2016, did win 1st overall, with 20% probablility. There was 80% chance not to win, so they got lucky and got Matthews.
- Winnipeg was 6th worst at 2016, did win the 2nd overall, with 7.8% probability. There was combined 84.7% chance not to win a TOP2 pick, so they got lucky and got Patrik Laine.
- Columbus was 4th last and did win the 3rd overall, passing 2 teams, EDM and VAN, from the standings position. Proability for a TOP3 pick was 29%.
I could think this was almost meaningless win for the CBJ in big picture, EDM would still have taken Puljujärvi and VAN a defenceman Juolevi. CBJ would have got their Dubois at 5th or 4th or 6th. Remember Jarmo trying to trade down knowing the situation, but no one was interested. He "hated" to pick Dubois that early, but there was a huge organizational need for a center after a Johansen-trade. I'm quite sure everybody at 3-7 got their favourable player.
At 2017 the percentage for 1st overall was lowered to 18% for the league-worst team (COL).
- New Jersey did win the 1st overall, with 8.5% probability. They were 5th worst at regular season. There was 91.5% chance not to win a 1st overall.
- Philadelphia did win the 2nd overall, with 2.4% probability. They were 13th worst at regular season. There was 95.4% chance not to win a TOP2 pick for Philadelphia
- Dallas did win the 3rd overall, with 6.4% probability. They were 8th worst at regular season. There was 81.0% probability not to win a TOP3 pick for Dallas.
So far...
League-Worst
4th worst
5th worst
6th worst
8th worst
13th worst
...have won the TOP3 pick. It's really a crapshoot. Especially that 2017 lottery was almost meaningless for teams positioned at 1-7, because there wasn't a huge talent drop at TOP3, like 2016 had it after TOP2 picks.
As for 2018, Dahlin is a real difference-maker like Matthews or Laine, but after that I think all teams from 2nd to 7th overall will get one of their favourable players.
If I combine the 2016-2017-2018 drafts:
1. Dahlin
2. Matthews
3. Laine
---------- talent drop
Hischier,Patrick, Keller, Dubois, Zadina, A.Svechnikov, M.Tkachuk, B.Tkachuk etc.
Juolevi, Heiskanen, Makar, Boqvist, Hughes, Bouchard etc.
If we don't win the lottery, I think it doesn't matter much if we are 2nd or 7th.
Last edited: