2015-2016 Penguins: Annual "Buy or Sell" Thread

[DawgPens]

Nick Bonino has more points at the end of the season than Brandon Sutter.

Click to read more...

 

[OilerPensfan97]

I say over.

 

[DawgPens]

I say over.

Ok ... And what is your over/under statement? The way this usually works (sorry I wasn't clear) is that you respond to the previous statement, and then pose one of your own.

 

[chrisp200]

Nick Bonino has more points at the end of the season than Brandon Sutter.

under


Connor Sheary plays his first NHL game

 

[Beauner]

under


Connor Sheary plays his first NHL game

Considering this is the Penguins, he'll probably have to due to injury. Over.

Perron scores 50 points. gordie isn't allowed to answer

 

[66-30-33]

Bones 70GP 18 goals 25 assists
Sutter 80GP 20 goals 15 assists

 

[Coach Travis]

I know how this works but I, uh, just want to make sure that other people, yeah that's it, other people who don't know how this works understand. You say "Over" if you agree and "Under" if you disagree?

 

[Beauner]

I know how this works but I, uh, just want to make sure that other people, yeah that's it, other people who don't know how this works understand. You say "Over" if you agree and "Under" if you disagree?

I guess so but I always thought these were supposed to be numbers based. Like "Pens will win 55 games" or "Crosby scores 35 goals". Then you answer whether it'll be over or under that amount.

 

[DawgPens]

I know how this works but I, uh, just want to make sure that other people, yeah that's it, other people who don't know how this works understand. You say "Over" if you agree and "Under" if you disagree?

Yeah, over=agree and under=disagree. Thanks for clarifying!

I probably should have my thread-initiating powers revoked ...

 

[Coach Travis]

Considering this is the Penguins, he'll probably have to due to injury. Over.

Perron scores 50 points. gordie isn't allowed to answer

I'll take over. 57 points to be exact!

Over/Under: Matt Murray plays at least 1 game for the Pittsburgh Penguins this season

 

[plaidchuck]

I'll take over. 57 points to be exact!

Over/Under: Matt Murray plays at least 1 game for the Pittsburgh Penguins this season

Over.

Over/Under: MJ still can't get the most out of this offense and is fired/replaced.

 

[Darth Vitale]

What happened to "Buy / Sell"? Can't we do that instead?

 

[Penguinator]

What happened to "Buy / Sell"? Can't we do that instead?

Yeah, less confusing to start with.

 

[Darth Vitale]

Buy or Sell it is!

MJ still can't get the most out of this offense and is fired/replaced.

I'm gonna.... sell. I don't know why but i think Johnston has the smarts to learn from his mistakes and certainly he's got enough talent now that a trained monkey could put at least two good lines together almost by chance. And the PP should carry the day when our full strength offense isn't clicking. I think he'll be here all season. Whether he gets fired in the off-season if we don't go far, is another matter.


Buy or Sell:
Platonikov will have a short learning curve and actually be a solid contributor to our offense most of the season, earning him a 2 year extension before the end of the season.

 

[penzweiser]

Buy or Sell it is!



I'm gonna.... sell. I don't know why but i think Johnston has the smarts to learn from his mistakes and certainly he's got enough talent now that a trained monkey could put at least two good lines together almost by chance. And the PP should carry the day when our full strength offense isn't clicking. I think he'll be here all season. Whether he gets fired in the off-season if we don't go far, is another matter.


Buy or Sell:
Platonikov will have a short learning curve and actually be a solid contributor to our offense most of the season, earning him a 2 year extension before the end of the season.

Sell

Buy or sell:
The penguins lead the league in goals by 10.

 

[Headshot77]

Sell

Buy or sell:
The penguins lead the league in goals by 10.

Buy.

Phil Kessel lands over 40 goals this season.

 

[Darth Vitale]

Buy.

Phil Kessel lands over 40 goals this season.

Buy. Just barely.


We have fewer than 200 man-games lost to injury.

 

[Konstantin Koltsov]

Buy.

Phil Kessel lands over 40 goals this season.

Sell. He'll get 37.

Buy. Just barely.


We have fewer than 200 man-games lost to injury.

Sell. The injury bug is always right around the corner.



Beau Bennett plays in at least 70 games this year.

 

[plaidchuck]

Buy.

Phil Kessel lands over 40 goals this season.

Sell.. just barely. I think the scoring will be spread out more on his line.

Buy/sell: Malkin plays more than 70 games this season.

 

[EVGENIMERLIN]

Buy. I think the injury bug isn't as bad this year with the changes they are making in the training/conditioning staff.

Buy or sell: Sundqvist plays at least half the season with the big club

 

[Darth Vitale]

Buy or sell: Sundqvist plays at least half the season with the big club

Buy unless we make another F acquisition. He seems like the logical candidate.


Buy or sell: assuming they play a similar number of games Olli will match or outscore Pouliot in total points.

 

[Asuna]

Buy unless we make another F acquisition. He seems like the logical candidate.


Buy or sell: assuming they play a similar number of games Olli will match or outscore Pouliot in total points.

Buy.

Crosby wins the Art Ross by 10+ points, buy/sell.

 

[EVGENIMERLIN]

Buy.

Crosby wins the Art Ross by 10+ points, buy/sell.

Buy. If he is healthy he has so many weapons to get him through injuries to his wingers. The PP should be a lot better and the D has some really good puck movers.

Buy or Sell MAF has 5+ shut outs

 

[Penguinator]

Buy.

Fleury get .920% again or more.

 

[EVGENIMERLIN]

.


Buy or sell: assuming they play a similar number of games Olli will match or outscore Pouliot in total points.

Hmm tough but I am going to sell. I think Letang will carry the offensive load on that pairing. I think Pouliot will score a few more goals than Olli