Gizmo Tkachuk
Registered Loser
I would have taken a 7th rounder in 2019. Glad to see we got something for Portland to replace Grimaldi, since he's likely joining the big club.
I respect your opinion but where do you get off saying these guys had proven much more by the time they signed. Matheson is a puck carrying defenseman who offensive scoring wise has degraded each year since he was at BC. Grimaldi had a good year at SA, and a solid career in the NCAA but he never put up the numbers that Hyman did his senior year. Rau was basically the same 40 pt player all three years with the Gophers.............much more???? You don't know if these guys or Hyman are much better prospects because you are looking at the fact he was drafted in the 5th round, and Berenson felt he was weak defensively and played him on the 3rd and 4th lines to better shape his two way game. Time, opportunity and the ability to take advantage of it will ultimately determine who the better players are.
As far as demanding playing time after graduating, tell me this. Does Gallant have to play him the remaining games or could he park him in the press box most of the time? It's all about burning a year in his ELC, not having him replace guys who are better suited for the playoff push. I'm not so sure he wouldn't have been a much better option than Kopecky down the stretch. He should have been given the chance.
I respect your opinion but where do you get off saying these guys had proven much more by the time they signed. Matheson is a puck carrying defenseman who offensive scoring wise has degraded each year since he was at BC. Grimaldi had a good year at SA, and a solid career in the NCAA but he never put up the numbers that Hyman did his senior year. Rau was basically the same 40 pt player all three years with the Gophers.............much more???? You don't know if these guys or Hyman are much better prospects because you are looking at the fact he was drafted in the 5th round, and Berenson felt he was weak defensively and played him on the 3rd and 4th lines to better shape his two way game. Time, opportunity and the ability to take advantage of it will ultimately determine who the better players are.
As far as demanding playing time after graduating, tell me this. Does Gallant have to play him the remaining games or could he park him in the press box most of the time? It's all about burning a year in his ELC, not having him replace guys who are better suited for the playoff push. I'm not so sure he wouldn't have been a much better option than Kopecky down the stretch. He should have been given the chance.
How do you define proven? Were either of those guys or for that matter Bjugstad or Matheson ever a finalist for the Hobey Baker Award? I'll save you the trouble........no........Zach Hyman was. So I think pigeonholing a guy who was forced by his coach to play 3rd and 4th line minutes to improve his defensive game the first three years of his NCAA career is unfair. He was never given the opportunity or possibly he didn't seize the opportunity, but it in no way should reflect on his present value to an NHL team.Hyman produced next to nothing until his senior year...
What does that tell you? That's not to say that he won't be a good player in the future, but thus far, Grimaldi and Rau have proven more.
You still don't get it. It's not about comparing an existing pro to an NCAA player. It's all about "seeing what's behind door number 3." Tallon and the Cats will never get that opportunity because he decided players have a pecking order based on where they were drafted. Tallon can't deal with the fact that the loophole gives a talented NCAA player tremendous negotiating power. It stinks, but those are the rules and you either anti up or fold your cards.Your own reasoning works against you. Pot meet kettle.
Both Hyman and McKegg are 23 with McKegg having two professional years under his belt. Lets see Hyman outproduce McKegg before we start bandying around names of higher regarded prospects.
I for one am glad that we are no longer in the position of having to bend to the requests of these players just to get them to sign. Sometimes the grass is not always greener on the otherside. Good luck to Hyman but I doubt in the scheme of things that this move will even be remembered in 3 years.
I respect your opinion but where do you get off saying these guys had proven much more by the time they signed. Matheson is a puck carrying defenseman who offensive scoring wise has degraded each year since he was at BC. Grimaldi had a good year at SA, and a solid career in the NCAA but he never put up the numbers that Hyman did his senior year. Rau was basically the same 40 pt player all three years with the Gophers.............much more???? You don't know if these guys or Hyman are much better prospects because you are looking at the fact he was drafted in the 5th round, and Berenson felt he was weak defensively and played him on the 3rd and 4th lines to better shape his two way game. Time, opportunity and the ability to take advantage of it will ultimately determine who the better players are.
As far as demanding playing time after graduating, tell me this. Does Gallant have to play him the remaining games or could he park him in the press box most of the time? It's all about burning a year in his ELC, not having him replace guys who are better suited for the playoff push. I'm not so sure he wouldn't have been a much better option than Kopecky down the stretch. He should have been given the chance.
You still don't get it. It's not about comparing an existing pro to an NCAA player. It's all about "seeing what's behind door number 3." Tallon and the Cats will never get that opportunity because he decided players have a pecking order based on where they were drafted. Tallon can't deal with the fact that the loophole gives a talented NCAA player tremendous negotiating power. It stinks, but those are the rules and you either anti up or fold your cards.
I don't blame the kid for keeping his options open, but you cannot blame the decision that was made by the Panthers org.
Blackmail another team, its cool.
I can easily defend the position taken by the org. Do you really want someone who has tried to blackmail his way onto the team to be playing here? I sure as hell don't.
Edit: apparently you edited your comment to mean the exact opposite of what it originally meant so I guess you can disregard this comment.
I guess this means we'll never be doing lunch. Oh well. But not a bad argument from a man who is a wealth of useless information.To imply that you have a better understanding about what goes in to the organization pecking order, outside factors, production, personal contract situation etc. is laughable.
The loophole exists, so Zach played his cards through his agent. The organization decided not to give in to his demands. Now you are saying before the kid even plays a 1 professional game that you know its a mistake? Spare me.
It's' amazing that at least 20 other teams had contacted his agent. Now do you really believe that all those teams have useless professional scouting staffs?Right, and Dale and his professional scouting staff decided he was not work the risk, suddenly you know better?
^Let's just all hope McKegg makes the team. Imagine Potvin saying "McKegg to Eggblad"
His daddy will just buy the team
Maybe he didn't want to sign here because Viola wouldn't sell the team to his dad.
I guess this means we'll never be doing lunch. Oh well. But not a bad argument from a man who is a wealth of useless information.
It's' amazing that at least 20 other teams had contacted his agent. Now do you really believe that all those teams have useless professional scouting staffs?
Enough with this love fest for Zach Hyman... holy ****... good riddance.
All of a sudden you make it sound like he was a can't-miss prospect.
Now sir, you know better than to question me when I post something. If you don't, I guess you will have to be schooled.Where was this reported?
Now sir, you know better than to question me when I post something. If you don't, I guess you will have to be schooled.
Check out the 7th sentence from the bottom.
http://www.thestar.com/sports/leafs...e-greg-mckegg-to-panthers-for-zach-hyman.html
Saw this earlier, good bye Hyman dont let the door hit you. In my eyes, theres only one situation here. Hyman knows he wont be able to prove himself playing as a 3C in Portland and has crazy bloated numbers in college. Kid just wants to get paid once rather than work through a system and play on a good upcoming team. Enjoy tank nation kiddo.
I mean he will because he'll get a long look at the NHL level.
Yup and as someone who lives in the GTA (greater toronto area) he'll be labeled as a bust, nobody, cancer and an outcast if he doesn't reproduce his NCAA numbers, he's opting for an elevator to Hell rather than climbing the stairs to a potential heaven, in the sun