rallymaster19
Guest
Okay so this notion came to me from the "How is Messier better than Yzerman..." thread where some people made the claim that Messier's 127-point 89-90 and 107-point 91-92 campaigns were somehow comparable to Yzerman's best season.
In 1988-89, Steve Yzerman put up 65 goals, 90 assists for 155 points, the most points by any player in a single season all-time not named Gretzky or Lemiuex. However, that season itself both 99 and 66 beat him in the scoring race, overshadowing Yzerman's accomplishments.
In points, the top 10 scorers were:
1. Mario Lemieux-PIT 199
2. Wayne Gretzky-LAK 168
3. Steve Yzerman-DET 155
4. Bernie Nicholls-LAK 150
5. Rob Brown-PIT 115
6. Paul Coffey-PIT 113
7. Joe Mullen-CGY 110
8. Jari Kurri-EDM 102
9. Jimmy Carson-EDM 100
10. Luc Robitaille-LAK 98
If you remove Yzerman and 66 and 99 and their linemates (Nicholls and Brown); Paul Coffey (also a Lemiuex teammate) becomes the highest scorer with 113 points. Steve Yzerman finishes with 37% more points than Coffey. He also finishes 27% higher than the next guy in goals, Joe Mullen (51).
Has there ever been a bigger gap points-wise at the end of the season (not including 99/66)? It's also more remarkable thinking of the linemates and teammates Yzerman had. No legitimate all-star caliber wingers or solid puck-moving defensemen (unless Chaisson counts). Of all the other great statistical seasons by other players, Espisito had Orr, Jagr had Lemiuex, LaFontaine had Mogilny's 76 goals, and Bossy had Trottier & Potvin. Had Yzerman had a Kurri or Borque, he may have hit 170-180.
To put it into perspective, if you remove Gretzky and Lemieux and their linemates from the 88-89 season, you have only Yzerman and 4 other players with 100 points or more in a high scoring era, with Coffey the highest at 113 points. Last season, there were 3 100-point scorers, with Malkin winning the Art Ross with also 113 points, and Ovechkin second with 110 points. Of all the hype we hear about Ovechkin, Malkin and Crosby, to match Yzerman's feat, it would be exactly like someone scoring 155 points last season. That's how good Yzerman was.
Because Yzerman played alongside the two greatest forwards who had their peaks also coincide with his, Stevie's 88-89 season gets grossly underrated. I'm going out and saying this was the greatest individual season all-time in the NHL by a skater not named Gretzky, Lemieux or Orr. Comments?
In 1988-89, Steve Yzerman put up 65 goals, 90 assists for 155 points, the most points by any player in a single season all-time not named Gretzky or Lemiuex. However, that season itself both 99 and 66 beat him in the scoring race, overshadowing Yzerman's accomplishments.
In points, the top 10 scorers were:
1. Mario Lemieux-PIT 199
2. Wayne Gretzky-LAK 168
3. Steve Yzerman-DET 155
4. Bernie Nicholls-LAK 150
5. Rob Brown-PIT 115
6. Paul Coffey-PIT 113
7. Joe Mullen-CGY 110
8. Jari Kurri-EDM 102
9. Jimmy Carson-EDM 100
10. Luc Robitaille-LAK 98
If you remove Yzerman and 66 and 99 and their linemates (Nicholls and Brown); Paul Coffey (also a Lemiuex teammate) becomes the highest scorer with 113 points. Steve Yzerman finishes with 37% more points than Coffey. He also finishes 27% higher than the next guy in goals, Joe Mullen (51).
Has there ever been a bigger gap points-wise at the end of the season (not including 99/66)? It's also more remarkable thinking of the linemates and teammates Yzerman had. No legitimate all-star caliber wingers or solid puck-moving defensemen (unless Chaisson counts). Of all the other great statistical seasons by other players, Espisito had Orr, Jagr had Lemiuex, LaFontaine had Mogilny's 76 goals, and Bossy had Trottier & Potvin. Had Yzerman had a Kurri or Borque, he may have hit 170-180.
To put it into perspective, if you remove Gretzky and Lemieux and their linemates from the 88-89 season, you have only Yzerman and 4 other players with 100 points or more in a high scoring era, with Coffey the highest at 113 points. Last season, there were 3 100-point scorers, with Malkin winning the Art Ross with also 113 points, and Ovechkin second with 110 points. Of all the hype we hear about Ovechkin, Malkin and Crosby, to match Yzerman's feat, it would be exactly like someone scoring 155 points last season. That's how good Yzerman was.
Because Yzerman played alongside the two greatest forwards who had their peaks also coincide with his, Stevie's 88-89 season gets grossly underrated. I'm going out and saying this was the greatest individual season all-time in the NHL by a skater not named Gretzky, Lemieux or Orr. Comments?