Big Phil
Registered User
- Nov 2, 2003
- 31,703
- 4,146
What is your list of the top 5 goalies of all time? keep in mind each one of the five on my list are considered favourites by somebody. Its very hard with goalies since its different eras and different styles of play but I tried to take everything into account. The first three especially could ALL be considered as #1 of all time. But this is why I went this way.
#1 Terry Sawchuk - Well no matter what this guy's name always pops into my head when I think of the alltime best. Why? Well for the first five years of his career he was invincible. After that he was still good and was a big reason the Leafs won the Cup in '67. First off he was a post season team all-star 7 times, not bad. He won 4 Cups and had 447 wins. Sawchuk had the sweet glove and could move very fast across the crease. His trade in '55 to Boston wasn't the best thing in his career but he came back wiht Detroit and was still very good. The main thing was his shutouts. 103. You can say that he played in a more defensive era. Okay fine but then why didnt Hall or Plante get more career shutouts than him? Well Terry was just the best.
#2 Dominik Hasek - Yeah I have him rated ahead of Roy. This is why. Six Vezinas to Roy's three. Plus look at his career. Most of his career has been on Buffalo. Those were not very good teams at all. They were below average teams. Geez Satan and Peca were their stars! But with Hasek he made them contenders every year just by his presence. And the psychological edge he gets even before the game starts compare to no other goalie. He led Buffalo deep in the playoffs in '97, '98, '99 and even '01. By '02 he had won a Cup with the Wings. Throw in a Gold Medal in Nagano in '98 and he's a proven champion. I dont like Hasek myself, but think about it, all those years he won the Vezina did anyone ever question it? Nope. And even Sawchuk never won a Hart Trophy, Hasek did it twice.
#3 Patrick Roy - First off he's not the greatest goalie to ever live. This is why. Roy was never on a bad team. From '85-95 Montreal was good. From '95-03 Colorado was even better. I like the fact that he won three Vezinas, and also four Cups. Plus holding the record of three Conn Smythe Trophies is pretty impressive too. But Roy could look mediocre at times too. He excelled in the playoffs but he didnt strike the fear into players the way Hasek did. I say put Roy on the 90s Sabres and they dont do as good as Hasek made them do. And to me that's got to be a knock against Roy.
#4 Glenn Hall - The most impressive stat? 11 post season all-star selections. Most ever by a goalie. 7 of them were the first team all-stars. Plus doing all this while playing in 502 straight games. That was durable. The knock I have against Hall is his lack of Cups. yeah it might be petty but in the Original six its hard to believe he only won one Cup with Chicago in '61. Yes he was in a lot of Cup finals as well and he helped St.Louis to three straight final appearances in '68-70 but two or three more Cups and he might be at the top of the list. Still, Glenn Hall could play for me anyday.
#5 Jacques Plante - You have to have Plante on this list. He won six Cups. 7 post season all-star selections. He lacked in the shutout department where Sawchuk excelled but he won a Hart Trophy in '62 which is rare for a goalie, from '50 to the present day on him, Hasek and Chuck Rayner have ever won one I believe. Now he did play on the greatest dynasty ever in the 50s Habs, so he wasnt the only star there thats for sure so you have to take that into account. But his numbers and hardware dont lie so he's #5.
Other guys who didnt crack my list but could have were Bernie Parent (didnt play long enough), Ken Dryden ( hard to say how good he was) Tony Esposito, who is top ten and eventually you'd have to say Brodeur will be mentioned among these guys too.
#1 Terry Sawchuk - Well no matter what this guy's name always pops into my head when I think of the alltime best. Why? Well for the first five years of his career he was invincible. After that he was still good and was a big reason the Leafs won the Cup in '67. First off he was a post season team all-star 7 times, not bad. He won 4 Cups and had 447 wins. Sawchuk had the sweet glove and could move very fast across the crease. His trade in '55 to Boston wasn't the best thing in his career but he came back wiht Detroit and was still very good. The main thing was his shutouts. 103. You can say that he played in a more defensive era. Okay fine but then why didnt Hall or Plante get more career shutouts than him? Well Terry was just the best.
#2 Dominik Hasek - Yeah I have him rated ahead of Roy. This is why. Six Vezinas to Roy's three. Plus look at his career. Most of his career has been on Buffalo. Those were not very good teams at all. They were below average teams. Geez Satan and Peca were their stars! But with Hasek he made them contenders every year just by his presence. And the psychological edge he gets even before the game starts compare to no other goalie. He led Buffalo deep in the playoffs in '97, '98, '99 and even '01. By '02 he had won a Cup with the Wings. Throw in a Gold Medal in Nagano in '98 and he's a proven champion. I dont like Hasek myself, but think about it, all those years he won the Vezina did anyone ever question it? Nope. And even Sawchuk never won a Hart Trophy, Hasek did it twice.
#3 Patrick Roy - First off he's not the greatest goalie to ever live. This is why. Roy was never on a bad team. From '85-95 Montreal was good. From '95-03 Colorado was even better. I like the fact that he won three Vezinas, and also four Cups. Plus holding the record of three Conn Smythe Trophies is pretty impressive too. But Roy could look mediocre at times too. He excelled in the playoffs but he didnt strike the fear into players the way Hasek did. I say put Roy on the 90s Sabres and they dont do as good as Hasek made them do. And to me that's got to be a knock against Roy.
#4 Glenn Hall - The most impressive stat? 11 post season all-star selections. Most ever by a goalie. 7 of them were the first team all-stars. Plus doing all this while playing in 502 straight games. That was durable. The knock I have against Hall is his lack of Cups. yeah it might be petty but in the Original six its hard to believe he only won one Cup with Chicago in '61. Yes he was in a lot of Cup finals as well and he helped St.Louis to three straight final appearances in '68-70 but two or three more Cups and he might be at the top of the list. Still, Glenn Hall could play for me anyday.
#5 Jacques Plante - You have to have Plante on this list. He won six Cups. 7 post season all-star selections. He lacked in the shutout department where Sawchuk excelled but he won a Hart Trophy in '62 which is rare for a goalie, from '50 to the present day on him, Hasek and Chuck Rayner have ever won one I believe. Now he did play on the greatest dynasty ever in the 50s Habs, so he wasnt the only star there thats for sure so you have to take that into account. But his numbers and hardware dont lie so he's #5.
Other guys who didnt crack my list but could have were Bernie Parent (didnt play long enough), Ken Dryden ( hard to say how good he was) Tony Esposito, who is top ten and eventually you'd have to say Brodeur will be mentioned among these guys too.