Proposal: Your best offer for this Sharks package
- Thread starter Kcoyote3
- Start date
780il
edm
780il
edm
- Sep 1, 2010
- 9,806
- 7,684
I guess depends in your definition if top 6. But offer seems light to me
Nash brought back a #1 and Lindgren, along with the Cap dumps of Spooner, Beleskey
Grabner yielded a 2d and an early 20's KHL D.
Maybe your 23 year old shows promise as depth or middle 6 F, but that's older, or less established, than top rentals often bring back
Maybe sweeten a bit more with a prospect like a Ready or Weatherby
Gotta admit, this is as much a Cap relief deal for SJS, as it is playoff readiness move
DaveMatthew
Bring in Peter
you don't have a 2019 1st
Rangers 2020 + 2021 2nds
expiring Zuc reduced
for
SJ 2020 1st, Labanc + ___________
somethin like dat
if we don't have a better offer for Zuc, which I expect will be the case
Rangers 2020 + 2021 2nds
expiring Zuc reduced
for
SJ 2020 1st, Labanc + ___________
somethin like dat
if we don't have a better offer for Zuc, which I expect will be the case
As a Habs fan I’d be willing to take a cap dump for another year or two max if Lebanc is included.
That is a deal that I’d be willing to do if the Sharks need the money to sign Karlsson or any other FA.
That is a deal that I’d be willing to do if the Sharks need the money to sign Karlsson or any other FA.
Gardiner for that package
Reilly Braun
Dermott zaitsev
Hainsey Oz
Labanc and karlsson give them nhl depth to make another move with johnsson or kapenen....Ie adding pesce to the above
And locked up for another year
Juxtaposer
Outro: Divina Comedia
Labanc has the same number of points as a player like Kapanen, but Labanc is garbage while Kapanen is gold. Oh HF Boards, never change.
The ONLY trash in that package is Karlsson, and even then he’s been pretty good of late.
The ONLY trash in that package is Karlsson, and even then he’s been pretty good of late.
Djp
Registered User
They don’t have a 2020 1st either
If they make the playoff this year buffalo gets their 1st, Ottawa gets their 2020 1st, if they don’t make playoffs then ithe buf/Ottawa picks flip.
PeguffaloSabres
Registered User
- Aug 7, 2011
- 96
- 30
This is a best offer scenario, but what you're offering is depth, so you're not going to be impressed with the return, unless my name is Chiarelli, then you can have McDavid. If I were running the Sabres, and without taking a lot of time to think about it, and the Sharks said, you need to take these players or I'll throw your daughter in a real shark tank, I'd offer the following.
Lebanc is the type of player the Sabres are looking for to fill depth scoring. Positive value, middle 6 winger who needs defensively reliable players with him.
Braun is a pretty decent RD, something the Sabres need.
M Karlsson is negative value
2019 45th ish overall pick - ok
Sabres have cap space for a couple years, so could take Karlsson. I really don't know what the Sharks needs are here, so I'll do my best for straight player value.
Lebanc, M Karlsson, Braun, 2019 2nd
Beaulieu, Rodrigues, AsplundThis offer gives the Sabres a top 4 D, freeing them up to trade Scandella to a team in need of a middle 6 LD. Sabres send Beaulieu to a team not only looking for cap space, but also a team that can offer playing time to a much revived Beaulieu to play over guys like Simek and Heed. Rodrigues is a multipositional center that doesn't offer as much offense as Lebanc, but thrives in possession, his own end and points/60. Asplund is a B prospect that plays the game the right way and all but assured to assume a bottom 6 defensive center role in the NHL in the next year or two. This will offset the cost of upgrading on D and scoring for the Sabres, as well as adding the 2nd round pick. Personally, I don't want to trade Asplund, and could likely be interchanged with Malone, who is a very similar player.
Gecklund
Registered User
PeguffaloSabres
Registered User
- Aug 7, 2011
- 96
- 30
Gecklund
Registered User
Yes a young winger that has scored 31 in 50ish games
A top 4 RHD
A solid (little overpaid admittedly but a guy GMs love) bottom 6 guy
A 2nd round pick
Definite trash.
16thOverallSaveUs
Danila Yurov Fan Club Executive Assistant
- May 2, 2018
- 18,795
- 11,752
Is labanc a center? Does he play 3rd line minutes in San Jose? I would do this trade sending back Zucker, Staal, and pateryn, but I’m not sure the cap works there. I’d want the 2nd to be a 1st too.
This is a best offer scenario, but what you're offering is depth, so you're not going to be impressed with the return, unless my name is Chiarelli, then you can have McDavid. If I were running the Sabres, and without taking a lot of time to think about it, and the Sharks said, you need to take these players or I'll throw your daughter in a real shark tank, I'd offer the following.
Lebanc is the type of player the Sabres are looking for to fill depth scoring. Positive value, middle 6 winger who needs defensively reliable players with him.
Braun is a pretty decent RD, something the Sabres need.
M Karlsson is negative value
2019 45th ish overall pick - ok
Sabres have cap space for a couple years, so could take Karlsson. I really don't know what the Sharks needs are here, so I'll do my best for straight player value.
This offer gives the Sabres a top 4 D, freeing them up to trade Scandella to a team in need of a middle 6 LD. Sabres send Beaulieu to a team not only looking for cap space, but also a team that can offer playing time to a much revived Beaulieu to play over guys like Simek and Heed. Rodrigues is a multipositional center that doesn't offer as much offense as Lebanc, but thrives in possession, his own end and points/60. Asplund is a B prospect that plays the game the right way and all but assured to assume a bottom 6 defensive center role in the NHL in the next year or two. This will offset the cost of upgrading on D and scoring for the Sabres, as well as adding the 2nd round pick. Personally, I don't want to trade Asplund, and could likely be interchanged with Malone, who is a very similar player.
This doesn't really offer the Sharks anything that they need now. This type of deal would happen in the off-season and at that point, they'd probably get a better offer than this. Beaulieu wouldn't get that much playing time honestly. The Sharks left side when healthy is Vlasic, Dillon, and either Ryan or Simek at this point. Beaulieu would certainly beat out the latter two but the Sharks aren't going to pay Beaulieu his worth to play that spot when they have to pay Karlsson and Pavelski and Meier this off-season a decent amount of coin to the point where they have to go cheap in certain spots. I do like Rodrigues but not for this sort of a deal and not when the Sharks have numerous forwards in their system to fill that spot but just need the opportunity.
Juxtaposer
Outro: Divina Comedia
This is a best offer scenario, but what you're offering is depth, so you're not going to be impressed with the return, unless my name is Chiarelli, then you can have McDavid. If I were running the Sabres, and without taking a lot of time to think about it, and the Sharks said, you need to take these players or I'll throw your daughter in a real shark tank, I'd offer the following.
Lebanc is the type of player the Sabres are looking for to fill depth scoring. Positive value, middle 6 winger who needs defensively reliable players with him.
Braun is a pretty decent RD, something the Sabres need.
M Karlsson is negative value
2019 45th ish overall pick - ok
Sabres have cap space for a couple years, so could take Karlsson. I really don't know what the Sharks needs are here, so I'll do my best for straight player value.
This offer gives the Sabres a top 4 D, freeing them up to trade Scandella to a team in need of a middle 6 LD. Sabres send Beaulieu to a team not only looking for cap space, but also a team that can offer playing time to a much revived Beaulieu to play over guys like Simek and Heed. Rodrigues is a multipositional center that doesn't offer as much offense as Lebanc, but thrives in possession, his own end and points/60. Asplund is a B prospect that plays the game the right way and all but assured to assume a bottom 6 defensive center role in the NHL in the next year or two. This will offset the cost of upgrading on D and scoring for the Sabres, as well as adding the 2nd round pick. Personally, I don't want to trade Asplund, and could likely be interchanged with Malone, who is a very similar player.
This is horrific. The Sharks do not need a single one of those players. Garbage offer.
Fistfullofbeer
Moderator
Melker may be the only one in there with little to no value. People acting like Braun and Labanc having no value just shows that they don’t know much about them or just undervalue them.
