I feel like this poll should be a lot closer, but Matthew has been playing dirty and caused ire.
Matt is a much more skilled player. Will have many more points in his career.
Brady is the calmer, smarter one who plays a complete game.
Neither guys you build a team around, yet it feels like the Sens are building around a shaky but talented structure in Stutzle, Tkachuk and Chabot. All the while the flames are collapsing with Matthew, Gaudreau and Monahan.
Both would do better with more talented linemates, so hard to see what full potential might be.
I'll go with Matthew by a hair. Will probably change my mind in 2 seasons time depending on how the Sens rebuild goes and what the flames do in the next 2 seasons.