Would you rather have Matthew or Brady?

[slapKing]

between the two Tkachuk brothers, which one would you take on your team?

Click to read more...

 

[NeverForget06]

Oilers fan saying Matthew. That guy could be a key piece to a cup winning team. I often think about if the Oilers would have taken him rather than Poolparty.

He's an idiot at times and I hate his guts but I really think some of it is because he plays on a Flames team with no spine outside of maybe Rasmus Andersson and Dillon Dube. It must be hard to put your body on the line every single night and play with heart when Jonny Hockey is floating around like a fairy and Boring Sean Mohahan doesn't even know what the score is.

Matthew is a great player. High skill and high impact. Wasted on the Flames

 

[Mrb1p]

Brady is a special player and if you have great pieces in place, him, but lets be honest, hes a 2nd line while his brother is a first liner.

The thing that makes is close is that i think Matt is a cancer.

 

[ThatsSoSlavin]

Matthew is the better offensive player but Brady is such a beast, I’ll go brady

 

[Garthinater]

Wow was not expecting Brady to take down shea weber. Even the announcers seemed surprised.

 

[GermanSpitfire]

i’m going to stick to my biases and say Tom Brady

 

[Mez]

last season it was clearly Matthew, this season its Brady. Matthew skates like he ate Twinkies and sat on the couch during the covid break.

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Definitely Auston, goalscorers like him don't grow on trees

 

[Captain97]

Wow was not expecting Brady to take down shea weber. Even the announcers seemed surprised.

I wouldn't call pushing someone into the net "taking down" but I was surprised how well he did in that fight all the same.

 

[Garthinater]

I wouldn't call pushing someone into the net "taking down" but I was surprised how well he did in that fight all the same.

I thought Brady landed the better of the punches and he managed to shove weber to the ice using the net.

But I honestly wasn't sure what to call it. Slightly won?

 

[JTToilinginToronto]

Depends on the sport I guess.

If football, I'm choosing Tom Brady all day.

 

[Rhaegar Targaryen]

Brady is the more unique player

 

[HabsInsider]

Matthew probably is the better player, but I like Brady's attitude much better. He's a winner that guy. Not being able to control your emotions is a sign of weakness and I don't care for Matthew's frequent outbursts.

Long story short I voted 'Brady.'

 

[Bouboumaster]

Brady so he can stop beating our ass

 

[phillipmike]

I thought this was an Auston Matthews vs Tom Brady poll when i originally opened it.

I thought "like who in the hell isnt taking Tom Brady?!!?"

 

[Mrb1p]

Wow was not expecting Brady to take down shea weber. Even the announcers seemed surprised.

Weber is old and soft.

Plus he didnt take him down.

 

[Tobias Kahun]

Brady.

better hockey player, and better fighter.

 

[Spawn]

Matthew is easily a better hockey player and frankly it’s not even close. In a vacuum he’d be my easy choice. His QO would make him unworkable on the oilers due to cap constraints. But he’s just a better player.

 

[Captain97]

I thought Brady landed the better of the punches and he managed to shove weber to the ice using the net.

But I honestly wasn't sure what to call it. Slightly won?

Weber landed some heavy blows as well, Bieksa called it a draw. But in most modern fights very rarely does anyone "win" them. It's a few punches that someone wrestles the other down.

Also because he is willing to and not get dummied by Weber I'll take Brady.

 

[ricky0034]

Definitely Auston, goalscorers like him don't grow on trees

but The Brady Bunch was huge and had a bunch of spinoffs

 

[Kcb12345]

People voting against Matthew I assume cause they just don't like him orrr

Easy choice to take him over his brother imo.

 

[jbeck5]

Weber landed some heavy blows as well, Bieksa called it a draw. But in most modern fights very rarely does anyone "win" them. It's a few punches that someone wrestles the other down.

Also because he is willing to and not get dummied by Weber I'll take Brady.

Weber basically only threw one superman punch and it went over Brady's head. Brady got 2-3 solid shots in, one that caught Weber in the face and made him slightly buckle, then Brady tossed him down against the net.

Slight win Brady, but I could see how Weber would have won if his big punch landed...but it didn't.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Weber landed some heavy blows as well, Bieksa called it a draw. But in most modern fights very rarely does anyone "win" them. It's a few punches that someone wrestles the other down.

Also because he is willing to and not get dummied by Weber I'll take Brady.

Brady won, Weber blows mostly missed.
I wasn’t surprised at all, if you watch Brady, just like his Dad.

 

[snipes]

Brady by a lot.

I can’t stand Matthew, but I’d easily take either or both of them on my team in the top 6.

If I had to pick, Brady though. Bigger, faster, stronger, tougher, and won’t alienate his teammates being a total rat like Matthew does.

 

[Perfect_Drug]

Matt Tkachuk being qualified at $9million next year should scare everyone.