Worst Avs defenseman over the last 5 seasons?

[cgf]

Stuart
Holden
HunnyBunny
SOB
ROB
Redmond
Zanon / Guenin

 

[Spender]

Zanon was on another level in terms of awfulness. His only defense was blocking the puck, and his only offense was icing it.

 

[LTC Pain]

Zanon then Guenin.

 

[missionAvs]

This is Zanon AINEC.

 

[The Shermanator]

 

[TheStranger]

These flashbacks to Zanon have one bright spot, I am outright grateful for Holden now.

 

[AllAboutAvs]

Count me in for Zanon as well.

 

[chet1926]

It's between Guenin and Zanon. They are just both worthless hockey players.

 

[RockLobster]

Stuart
Holden
HunnyBunny
SOB
ROB
Redmond
Zanon / Guenin

Are you saying that Stuart is the worst, or that we should start from the bottom?

Personally, I think that anyone who would choose Brad Stuart as the "worst" from this listing of Avs defenseman, must have just a personal bias against him...no way he's been a worse defenseman than Zanon or Guenin.

 

[Coloradorov]

Stuart
Holden
HunnyBunny
SOB
ROB
Redmond
Zanon / Guenin

That's my good to worst list as well, but I'd switch Rob and Sob.

 

[cgf]

Are you saying that Stuart is the worst, or that we should start from the bottom?

Personally, I think that anyone who would choose Brad Stuart as the "worst" from this listing of Avs defenseman, must have just a personal bias against him...no way he's been a worse defenseman than Zanon or Guenin.

Should've cleared that up but no, I was just starting with the best and working my way down to the worst.

 

[Tommy Shelby]

Could you imagine if they were all here at the same time?

Hunwick-Stuart
Holden-ROB
SOB-Guenin
Redmond
Zanon

Coached by Sacco.

 

[Lord Moriarty007]

Zanon wins this clearly.

 

[Freudian]

A world where Greg Zanon get a two year $4.5M contract is so so unfair.

 

[LieutenantDangle]

That goal might be the first Avs goal I saw live at night. It was right around the time I started watching live games. I watched it on a really choppy stream. Stuck with me...

I miss Mueller. damn injuries and such. he had so much more potential than pap

 

[Alex Jones]

I mean really Tom Preissing, but Greg Zanon.

 

[Alex Jones]

Also Brett Clark last played for the Avs in 2010, let's not let our parade of terrible players make us forget how bad he was

 

[CalderKing21]

I badly want to say Hunwick but it was easily Zanon. I still hate Hunwick more though because of where he played.

 

[The Kingslayer]

I badly want to say Hunwick but it was easily Zanon. I still hate Hunwick more though because of where he played.

I hate Sacco more for his playing Hunwick 20 mins a night with EJ lol. Poor EJ.

 

[Foppa2118]

[MOD] Please note that there's a bug in the poll and it doesnt allow you to cast your vote . We are sorry for the inconvenience , tigervixxxen can make a new thread with a new poll , if she wishes to do so.

Thank you

Frenchy [MOD]

Mmmmm, this sounds fishy. Clearly Frenchy is a huge Greg Zanon fan. It's ok Frenchy, we understand. First step is admitting it. Then apologizing to everyone you've hurt because of your illness.

 

[CoachBadkitten]

Maybe I'm crazy (also a fan of his) but I think Hunwick is easily the 2nd best in this group. The year we traded for him he was truly awful but the next couple years after that weren't near as bad. And I think in a 3rd pairing role he looks absolutely fine. Only reason we despised him so much is because he played 20+ mins a night under Sacco. The Zanon's and SOB's didn't play near that amount and still looked awful.

 

[AvsRobin]

Greg Zanon by a country mile.

Hunwick should not be mentioned from anyone in this thread IMO.

 

[quesosauce]

heh, thanks for the shout out in the OP

i seriously think its guenin

someone posted a vid/gif of him pointing to a man for someone else to cover, then he himself goes and covers that man as well, comepletely leaving his man wide open for a goal. i cannot abide this kind of terrible


all the others on this list (maybe zanon) had/have some redeeming qualities. at at least zanon had experience and a wicked beard

guenin is awful

 

[Congo Jack]

1) Zanon
2) Guenin
3) 20 minutes a night Hunwick

I wonder if anyone will be able to dethrone Zanon, his suckage was truly on a whole 'nother level.

 

[Balthazar]

Where's Ryan Wilson?