wings defense

[A1Portable]

We need to do something in the realm of offer sheeting a guy like Subban. It's only one game but I cant recall the defense looking so helpless.

I got slammed around here last year for saying this. But Quincey is painful to watch. Everybody looked bad last night, but man.. Maybe I just have something against him but I can't stand the guy.

I generally agree. Quincy is a nice guy, I suspect, but he would not be a top 4 defenseman on a contending team.

 

[Mickey Redmond*]

Send Quincey to GR, bring up whoever the Griffin's number 1 defenseman is.

 

[HTT3*]

Pens fan coming in peace.

Can't speak for the other guys but Orpik is not likely to be available and it would cost more to get him than you might think. Legitimate 1st pairing D with his style of game don't grow on trees, and short of a prospect who has no experience yet, we don't have any other D who fit his mold. Anyway Penguins are going to be buyers all the way this year, not sellers. I doubt if you could get Scuds from LA either. Not much reason to trade a guy like that, in their situation.

Will be interested to see how Holland and Babcock react to yesterday. Only one game but was surprising the way it went. You guys know your team a lot better than I do but if you guys end up struggling / in rebuild mode I can't see Holland doing it the "build through young prospects" road. He's going to go out and be a big player on the FA market this summer. You guys always find a way to be competitive.

What's the status of Simon Despres? He's the guy I was hoping Holland was going to take in the first round... then we traded down to get Landon Ferraro and Andrej Nestrasil.

Still boggles my mind why he didn't take Despres. Pens have lots of good dmen.

 

[KasperTheGrittyGhost]

Swap one of the umpteenth bottom 6ers for a defensive defenseman like Volchenkov or Tallinder and we'll be just fine. That slides everyone else down.

Kronwall-Ericsson
Smith-Tallinder/Volch
CC/Kindl/White/Q

 

[pdd]

We need to do something in the realm of offer sheeting a guy like Subban.

This was possible before the Gomez buyout. Montreal now has $11m in cap space for next season.

Had the Wings offer sheeted Subban for $5.25/5 (or anything more than $4.5m/2) before the Gomez buyout, Montreal would not have been able to match it due to tagging rules; it would have put them over the cap for next year's roster.

Now? Not possible. Montreal would simply match the offer. When you get over ~$6.7m, compensation increases to 2x1st+2nd+3rd. Montreal might be willing to take that package. After ~$8.4m, it's 4 1sts, which Montreal should take for two reasons. First, they get four extra first round choices to help build their young club. Second, they're not paying a good defenseman superstar-level wages just because someone else was having trouble finding a defenseman. Markov, Gorges, Kaberle, and Emelin can more than hold down the fort if they replace Subban were someone to offer that kind of money. And they have top defense prospects like Tinordi coming up.

 

[Tomas W]

Better just wait for Jones....

 

[Marky9er]

What's the status of Simon Despres? He's the guy I was hoping Holland was going to take in the first round... then we traded down to get Landon Ferraro and Andrej Nestrasil.

Still boggles my mind why he didn't take Despres. Pens have lots of good dmen.

I heard he's being traded for Datsyuk. Jk, but I don't think we could get him for a fair value.

 

[JBauerly97]

I can't see Holland doing an offer sheet-for anybody-ever.

 

[InjuredChoker]

What's the status of Simon Despres? He's the guy I was hoping Holland was going to take in the first round... then we traded down to get Landon Ferraro and Andrej Nestrasil.

Still boggles my mind why he didn't take Despres. Pens have lots of good dmen.

Or just take ROR.. I like hindsights.

 

[ProPAIN]

I can't see Holland doing an offer sheet-for anybody-ever.

Unfortunately...this. It's not a criticism. That's their policy. Down the line it could happen to us (imagine someone screwing the Wings for Jarnkrok, Smith, Ouellet, etc.). It sets a precendent.

However, if a trade can be done...

 

[Actual Thought*]

I think the Wings are too far from having a competitive roster. Holland can't make enough moves this year to compete for the cup. I think we will be sellers in just a couple of weeks.

 

[fimoknete]

And a salary cap. Sorry that not everyone on the team can be on Datsyuk's level like you would like.

what has the wings to do with the salary cap at the moment?

 

[fimoknete]

I think the Wings are too far from having a competitive roster. Holland can't make enough moves this year to compete for the cup. I think we will be sellers in just a couple of weeks.

first step would be a trade at all. and i dont talk about expendable player. waiting for that for years now.

 

[SoupNazi]

what has the wings to do with the salary cap at the moment?

I have no idea what that means.

 

[fimoknete]

we dont even hit the cap even when we aer signing 2 more player and kick two other out. but holland will never trade again. so salary cap is irrelevant now for the wings.

 

[SoupNazi]

we dont even hit the cap even when we aer signing 2 more player and kick two other out. but holland will never trade again. so salary cap is irrelevant now for the wings.

Yeah. But suppose we spend to the cap this year, and then the cap goes down. Will you blame Holland for the cap going down too?

 

[Puckgenius*]

Smith has top 4 potential

 

[Run the Jewels]

I ****ing hate Kyle Quincey so ****ing much.

 

[Zetterberg4Captain]

I ****ing hate Kyle Quincey so ****ing much.

dont worry, he just needs time to get adjusted to hockey..

 

[JmanWingsFan]

Pick up Vandermeer on waivers...

Kronwall-Ericsson
Smith-Lashoff
Vandermeer-White

 

[WingedWheel1987]

dont worry, he just needs time to get adjusted to hockey..

Yeah, he just woke up from a coma last week and is playing hockey for the first time in his life.

 

[ZDH]

Smith has top 4 potential

At worst. Without him and our defensive outlook would be downright depressing.

 

[ProPAIN]

Pick up Vandermeer on waivers...

Kronwall-Ericsson
Smith-Lashoff
Vandermeer-White

I think it's inevitable at this point. Just switch Smith and Ericsson. I'm not comfortable with two rookies on the same pairing.

Or even Mike Commodore? Someone hit him up on Twitter and ask!

 

[Sheldon Keefe]

Do you guys actually watch Subban play or you just base yourself on his overrated reputation? No way in hell we should give a 1st for him. NO WAY.

 

[Mickey Redmond*]

Smith got beat badly tonight, very badly.