My gripe with the blue collar image is what another poster mentioned: it makes us a perennial underdog. It's a loser mentality. Detroit doesn't have a blue collar image, even though it's the definition of a blue collar city, they have a winning mentality. I'd rather the Sabres have that as opposed to trying the loser mentality blue collar image that's been the Sabres identity along with finishing 7th-10th every year.
Being blue collar means you work hard and its associated with being tough/gritty. Boston has a team that fits that mold and has played for two Cups, winning one. The Hawks are pretty much built with a bunch of highly talent players with a blue collar work ethic as are the Kings. I would argue any team that wins the Cup has to have this characteristic to go along with their talent.
Being the underdog usually means you have less talent/ability than your opponent. Its not synonymous with being blue collar.
And what's wrong with being an underdog, you might ask? Underdogs aren't expected to win. It's a surprise when they do. It seems as if Buffalo always the underdog in almost every sport, I'm tired of it.
You may want to revisit our sports history. I can think of only one Buffalo sports team that did anything and was viewed as the underdog while doing it. The Hasek era Sabres. And even that team road the wave of one of the greatest goalies of all time.
-On our previous run to the Cup we were one of the best teams in the game (in a 3 way tie for the most points in the league). We had one of the most excited lines in the game (The French Connection) with each member in the top 10 in the league in points. We were not the scrappy underdog.
-Coming out of the 04-05 lockout we had one of the best and deepest teams in the NHL. A team that eventually won the Presidents trophy. They could hardly be viewed as the scrappy underdog either.
-During the Bills runs to the Super Bowl they dominated the AFC and were favored in their first Superbowl. Ironically the grind it out "blue collar" Giants beat the high octane favored Bills in that first Superbowl.
I think too many are projecting their frustrations over the last several years onto Nolan and the idea of a blue collar work ethic. At the end of the day the team needs a strong work ethic as a foundation so it can have success down the road when more talent is added. That will be the case regardless of who the coach is.