"Who Was Better, Crosby or MacKinnon?" Has Become A Valid Question
- Thread starter Neutrinos
- Start date
- Status
UpGoesRupp
Registered User
The difference for me is that Crosby would be named captain if they were on the same team, at any point.
IWantSakicAsMyGM
Registered User
You mean the year that Crosby and Malkin only played half the season, allowing a 1.27 PPG Daniel Sedin to win the Ross?
Where do you think Daniel Sedin ranks compared to the next tier of guys from today like Pasta/Panarin/Rantanen/Matthews/Draisaitl/Pettersson? Exactly the same caliber of player?
Lafleurs Guy
Guuuuuuuy!
- Jul 20, 2007
- 74,915
- 44,611
Mackinnon is a great player. He is not Crosby.
Comparing raw stats without factoring in the era no sense.
I’d also say this is a pretty lopsided thread. Not much more to discuss here.
Comparing raw stats without factoring in the era no sense.
I’d also say this is a pretty lopsided thread. Not much more to discuss here.
- Status
