NFL: Who is the most notable QB you'd rank Mahomes ahead of for career performance?

[BKIslandersFan]

Aaron Rodgers.

Mahomes is already better.

 

[tacogeoff]

Mahomes is already better.

yup. that's what I said.

"Who is the most notable QB you'd rank Mahomes ahead of for career performance?"

Or did the OP mean The most notable QB youd rank ahead of Mahomes for career performance?

 

[BKIslandersFan]

I'm assuming you mean current players?

Tom Brady
Mayyyyyyyyyyyyyybe Ben Roethlisberger


Other than that, I really don't think there's anyone who can compare.

You know what? Screw it, I am gonna say it.

Patrick Mahomes is a better QB than Tom Brady. Tom Brady's TEAM accomplishment should not cloud the fact that Mahomes is better in every way in terms of skills.

 

[Rodgerwilco]

You know what? Screw it, I am gonna say it.

Patrick Mahomes is a better QB than Tom Brady. Tom Brady's TEAM accomplishment should not cloud the fact that Mahomes is better in every way in terms of skills.

The thread was more geared toward career performance, in which you can't deny Brady's career achievements. He's got more Super Bowls than Mahomes has even been in the league.

At this point in their careers I'd agree that Mahomes is physically better, he's obviously a better runner than Brady's ever been and has youth on his side. But from a football IQ stand-point and overall knowledge and/or vision I'm not so sure I'd automatically give it to Mahomes quite yet.

 

[member 157595]

You know what? Screw it, I am gonna say it.

Patrick Mahomes is a better QB than Tom Brady. Tom Brady's TEAM accomplishment should not cloud the fact that Mahomes is better in every way in terms of skills.

In terms of physical skills, sure. There are tons of QB's more physically gifted than Tom Brady.

Physical skills are just one component of what makes a QB great, however, and if you're going to tell me you think Mahomes' football IQ is greater than Brady's, well, there's no point in continuing this discussion.

 

[BKIslandersFan]

In terms of physical skills, sure. There are tons of QB's more physically gifted than Tom Brady.

Physical skills are just one component of what makes a QB great, however, and if you're going to tell me you think Mahomes' football IQ is greater than Brady's, well, there's no point in continuing this discussion.

Football IQ?


OH you mean Bill Belichick's coaching. Ok I see how you could make that mistake.

The thread was more geared toward career performance, in which you can't deny Brady's career achievements. He's got more Super Bowls than Mahomes has even been in the league.

At this point in their careers I'd agree that Mahomes is physically better, he's obviously a better runner than Brady's ever been and has youth on his side. But from a football IQ stand-point and overall knowledge and/or vision I'm not so sure I'd automatically give it to Mahomes quite yet.

Superbowl wins are individual achievements? I see.