I don't know why so many of you guys are convinced that both Scuds and RR will be re-signed. I understand that DL mentioned their potential signing in the off-season, but we still have Mitchell and Greene under contract.
RR
Scuds
Greene
WM
That's 4 SAH dmen at a pretty hefty cost imo.
I say as long as WM is back, we sign one of RR or Scuds, NOT both. And I would definitely prefer RR over Scuds.
Because of DL's rhetoric when talking about Mitchell's injuries. It doesn't sound optimistic, and given Mitchell's past history, it is questionable that he returns. Mitchell is a question mark and Scuderi is healthy and proven durable.
Lombardi will want three veteran stay-at-home defenseman on the line, and it is questionable whether or not Mitchell will show signs of improvement by the summer time. These decisions have to be made in weeks, it isn't that far away, we are talking about free agents, we can't wait till camp. DL will want the sure thing, and that is to re-sign Regehr and Scuderi and be set with it.
Scuds is a proven warrior with two rings, letting him walk in favor of Ellerby would be a mistake if you can afford to keep him, and we can.
If Mitchell comes back, then great, that is a bonus, and then we jettison his contract after the year is done. There are worse things in the world than having Greene and Scuderi shut down opponents on a bottom pairing.