Why does his shooting percentage mean that he isn't a superstar? Here are the shooting percentages of the top 5 goal scorers: Seguin - 19.8% Nash - 20.0% Tarasenko - 16.3% Stamkos - 17.8% Malkin - 20.0% Everyone on this list is shooting at an abnormally high percentage. Who cares? You wouldn't say Stamkos doesn't deserve to be considered one of the league's top scorers just because of his shooting percentage. The fact is, in Nash has played two full seasons in NY: one where he was on pace for 36G+36A, and one where he had concussion issues all year. This season, he's been the best player on the ice as often as not. He has absolutely been playing like a superstar.