Where does Malkin Actually Rank?

[Poppy Whoa Sonnet]

Wherever Scottie Pippin is.

 

[tom_servo]

Wherever Scottie Pippin is.

Did Scotty Pippen win an MVP, two scoring titles, and a playoff MVP?

Malkin isn't as much in the shadow of Crosby as he's just never healthy for a full 82.

 

[AppsSyl]

I think Malkin falls in the 25-50 range at this point. Him not being in the top 100 is a joke.

 

[GoldenKnight]

Top 20. The extra Cup and playoff scoring title moved him up the ranks a little, I have him #18 on my list.

 

[Aaaaaaaaaaaaa]

Well he's at least on par with Sid, however Tsn is more dangerous than Putins statemedia. Tsn and their bias media hypemachine followers boosts him right now while and nuking/ignoring the rest. Crosby is of course a very great player, but the political award crap should be left out when compairing players.

Then why are you bringing it up?

I'd say he is definitely in Yzerman/Sakic territory.

 

[Mr Spock]

I'm bringing it up because I believe the medias immense impact on hf bandwagoners and others is sad to see. Media run the award hype. Awards are not voted in a fair way and thevnon Canadians often get discriminated against.

 

[Paxton Fettel]

If Crosby is top 5, then Malkin is top 6 for sure.

 

[NoMessi]

I'm bringing it up because I believe the medias immense impact on hf bandwagoners and others is sad to see. Media run the award hype. Awards are not voted in a fair way and thevnon Canadians often get discriminated against.

I agree with this. The trophies are overrated, the actual play is underrated. I agree that Crosby is Greater due to circumstances and health, but I still believe Malkin is Better.

Anyway, because the all-time lists are about who is greater - Crosby have built himself a good case and are trending his way inside top 10. Hard to rank a player while he is still playing.

Malkin on the other hand is harder since a lot of his good years he have been injured, and also trying to play through the injuries which actually led to him being under 1PPG one year.

I have him somewhere inside top 30 now. He will probably finish inside top 15 and Crosby inside top 10.

 

[Incognito]

Top 10-15, I have him slightly higher ranked than Crosby who is in 15-25 range.

You seriously have Malkin ranked above Crosby all-time? That's ... an interesting opinion

 

[CatOTails]

um...his rookie season

bravo

 

[Cubs2024WSChamps]

101

Not one spot higher

 

[Barry Amsterdam]

He's not even the best malkin

 

[jimstark]

Top 10-15, I have him slightly higher ranked than Crosby who is in 15-25 range.

I agree !!