Brian Lee being taken 9th overall was just one of many of John Muckler's colosal blunders in his time in Ottawa. The guy had a 3 man scouting staff....
Everyone and their dog knew Marc Staal and Anze Kopitar would be the better selections but instead they had to go "off the board" to get the next Redden.
Lee himself has been an interesting case. His time in the AHL was nothing spectacular and he had an attitude when he was sent back down after his strong first showing in the NHL. Since, then he's completely changed his game from an offensive puck mover to a physical stay at home defender. Its actually amusing to hear some Sens fans rip Lee for being soft, when he's probably our most physical and consistant defender.
After being waived and sitting in the press box for the early stages of the year he came in and was paired with Chris Phillips for the latter part of the year and the two looked like a top shut down pairing. They did a number on St. Louis, Stamkos and Kovalchuk in particular a few times down the stretch.
Lee's offensive game has essentially vanished but he's very efficient with his outlets and makes simple plays that are needed from your top 4 defense-first guys. His shot is weak but the rest of his tools are great. He's big, mean and a really strong skater. I can say with a lot of confidence that he's ready for a top 4 role in the NHL. He's a bust in the sense that he'll never be that top pairing point producer but a good NHL defenseman nonetheless.
Truthfully, he never deserved to be benched for as long as he did. He played well early in the season imo. Its been fairly well documented that Murray nor Clouston like the guy and he's gotten the short straw in Ottawa for awhile. I expect he'll be shipped out when he recoupes some value but he'll do well where ever he goes and a lot of teams will be kicking themselves that they didn't pick him up off waivers last winter. His game is similar to a Jan Hejda or Josh Gorges now.
I hope he sticks in Ottawa but we all know Karlsson and Rundblad are probably going to be taking those 2 top 4 RD spots for many years to come so it may be best for Lee to move on when he gets the chance but I'd certainly love the idea of Lee in our bottom pairing.