Proposal: W. Nylander for Max Domi

[BlueBaron]

Just go check all the Matthews threads.It;s not just a handfull of Leaf fans .It's everyone of them in any Matthews thread.I guess your just one on the outside looking in.

Most people consider Matthews a top player and Nylander a good.

You are producing fake news.

 

[Cobra Commander]

I'd gamble that they aren't garbage picks, especially if you're handcuffing yourself with that contract

That makes ZERO sense, the picks will be worse because adding Marner would make us a MUCH better team. That contract would be beautiful for us, in 5 years 14 mil wil be a bargain for a guy like him.

 

[lifelonghockeyfan]

I don't see Montreal accepting it at all. Domi is cheaper and more importantly has found a niche with the Habs. Now admit, that Nylander might have greater upside. But Habs are fighting for the playoffs this year and need Domi. There is no reason to believe that Nylander is going to be good this season.

 

[Randy Randerson]

That makes ZERO sense, the picks will be worse because adding Marner would make us a MUCH better team. That contract would be beautiful for us, in 5 years 14 mil wil be a bargain for a guy like him.

there's a thing called a salary cap, you can bet on $14M being a small portion of that in the future but its like a 40% overpay in year 1 for a cap that averages less than a 5% increase each year but that would be a bad bet. Anyway, have at it

 

[Ciccio1980]

there's a thing called a salary cap, you can bet on $14M being a small portion of that in the future but its like a 40% overpay in year 1 for a cap that averages less than a 5% increase each year but that would be a bad bet. Anyway, have at it

Leaf fans should tell marner to sign a 14m offer sheet and the produce at a 20 point pace till he's bought out

 

[Randy Randerson]

Leaf fans should tell marner to sign a 14m offer sheet and the produce at a 20 point pace till he's bought out

he's a talented guy and he'll produce, but I think a team with him as their best player would end up on a Calgary-esque situation with Gaudreau, it's not terrible but its sort of a team without an identity and inconsistently successful

 

[ole ole]

Most people consider Matthews a top player and Nylander a good.

You are producing fake news.

Yes most non-Leaf fans do consider Matthews a top player and Nylander a good player.
That's a far cry from the 2nd best and an elite superstar player.
See the difference.

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Domi is only signed for 1 more year after this one at 3,150,000$, if he was to sign an extension for a trade than yes he would definitely be worth more because he is a Center and is out producing Nylander this season.

But the difference is that Nylander is expandable to the Leafs, and up for trade, while Domi is indespensible to the Habs and not for trade!

You actually believe the crap you’re writing don’t you lol. Of course he’s outproducing Nylander, he’s played two games. Good lord lol

 

[The List Of Jericho]

This thread should be buried in the bottom of an ocean. It's basically who is better, Domi or Nylander, through genetic or voodoo means. And here's what I say. If the Leafs and Habs met in the 1st round, Habs would win. Keep Nylander as a souvenir.

You Hab fans are hilarious lol, when the big dip happens you’ll run and hide.

 

[Jee]

No thanks Nylander sucks

 

[Kotkaniemi15]

Most unrealistic and useless trade thread I've ever seen on HF. Nylander just signed a long-term deal in Toronto which he held out months to get. The team clearly wants him there as they've said they won't move him. Nylander also came out and said Kyle Dubas told him that he won't trade him as long as he's the GM. The Habs just traded for Domi who has emerged as a PPG centre while developing sick chemistry with Drouin. The Habs would be foolish to trade one of their best young forwards who wants to be there and is on a great contract. He's perfect for the Habs system and it would make little to no sense to move him. Some Leafs fans are going to overrate Nylander and some Habs fans are going to overrate Domi. The two are pretty similar in value and they're both important parts of each team's core. Both teams don't make this trade.

 

[A1LeafNation]

Lol no

 

[Swedish Gretzky]

Most unrealistic and useless trade thread I've ever seen on HF. Nylander just signed a long-term deal in Toronto which he held out months to get. The team clearly wants him there as they've said they won't move him. Nylander also came out and said Kyle Dubas told him that he won't trade him as long as he's the GM. The Habs just traded for Domi who has emerged as a PPG centre while developing sick chemistry with Drouin. The Habs would be foolish to trade one of their best young forwards who wants to be there and is on a great contract. He's perfect for the Habs system and it would make little to no sense to move him. Some Leafs fans are going to overrate Nylander and some Habs fans are going to overrate Domi. The two are pretty similar in value and they're both important parts of each team's core. Both teams don't make this trade.

Yes I know this trade is extremely unlikely. It was an interesting thought experiment to see how people would assess the value of these players, the value of toughness/grit, and skill.

I wasnt expecting people to go overboard and take things personal anf grossly overrate or attack the players involved.

 

[HuGo Sham]

leafs fans and brass would love to have gotten their hands on max. you kidding me? tie is a legend in hog town

 

[Cobra Commander]

You actually believe the crap you’re writing don’t you lol. Of course he’s outproducing Nylander, he’s played two games. Good lord lol

Outproducing as in, Domi is doing things thing season that Nylander has been incapable of doing.

 

[Cobra Commander]

Yes I know this trade is extremely unlikely. It was an interesting thought experiment to see how people would assess the value of these players, the valie of toughness/grit, and skill.

I wasnt expecting people to go overboard and take things personal anf grossly overrate or attack the players involved.

Your original trade proposal explanation was laughable.

 

[Cobra Commander]

there's a thing called a salary cap, you can bet on $14M being a small portion of that in the future but its like a 40% overpay in year 1 for a cap that averages less than a 5% increase each year but that would be a bad bet. Anyway, have at it

My forwards are on great deals, I can afford him at 14 mil no problem, and that would crush the leafs.

 

[Randy Randerson]

My forwards are on great deals, I can afford him at 14 mil no problem, and that would crush the leafs.

sounds good man, about time we had an NHL decision maker on here, pull the trigger

 

[Randy Randerson]

delete

 

[REALTALK81]

All i can say is Doug Ford.

They are all meat puppets to me. It was more a play on Will Ny's magnificent flow.

 

[Scintillating10]

I would like to see Max domi in a Leafs jersey. He seems to rise to the occasion and does not shy away from physical aspect of the game.

Leafs need: more skilled toughness, cap room. Domi is the rare blend of physical and also skilled
Habs need: more skill all around, 1C. Nylander would arguably have the higher offensive ceiling and is signed for longer term.



I'm not saying remotely likey, but interesting to consider thoughts?

Google Image Result for https://thumbs.gfycat.com/MammothBlueBellfrog-size_restricted.gif

No way love Domi. Hate Nylander contract

 

[The List Of Jericho]

Outproducing as in, Domi is doing things thing season that Nylander has been incapable of doing.

Like what? Cheap shot guys in the pre-season?

 

[voyageur]

This thread is still open, Jesus Christ.

Swedish meatballs for Lamb chops.

 

[Skin Tape Session]

Both teams say no

Sure they do lmfao, mtl drives domi in a tie domi leafs jersey all the way to the ACC not stoping once. Both teams say no he says._.Bwahahaha

 

[Skin Tape Session]

This thread is so hf.Just trash. Mtl says no ,good god the agenda. Suck it HF, Matthews,Rielly,Tavares,Marner,Nylander>>>>>>>>mtl/edm._.Suck it(Does DX chop)

 

[LeHab]

Mtl and toronto say no, next.