I was going to follow up with the same kind of response. I was just trying to see just how familiar KA is with Tuch to make such a definitive statement. I was expecting him to at least make some claim about the player and then I'd share my personal impressions, but I fell asleep.Much better response.
I think there's a categorical difference between saying Tuch doesn't seem all that special to me and Tuch isn't anything special. It should have been plainly obvious from my language that I wasn't trying to academically compare notes on the guy, but to assert that it's a little silly to make such a definitive judgment on a player with only 1 year of experience after what I can only presume is a small handful of games of his watched at best.
Also, people ask others to prove negatives here all the time. Not sure what the issue is.
I'm far more interested in what it is about him that you think makes him, as a guy fresh off his rookie year, nothing special.What is he, your son?
I didn't say he was bad.
Why don't you explain what makes him special that i'm apparently missing?
I'm asking you to back it up. You don't have to if you don't want, of course. It's within your rights to ignore me. I just want to hear the justification. I know I can't add much more than Derriko except to say that Tuch is uniquely fast for a guy his size who opts to play a prototypical PWF style game. But even with that one factoid I've provided more analysis than you.