Tatar Shots
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2014
- 5,715
- 1,716
Pretty clear teams are refusing to spend money unless it’s a great deal for them. I’m guessing the ask to take on Fleury were absurd
So Vegas values a 1st and 2nd round pick plus 7mil of Fleury over Nate Schmidt?
To me that is just dumb. If they move Fleury they get to keep Nate. And a dman like him is basically what you would pay at the deadline anyway(1st and 2nd). So they could have avoided all of this just by accepting what teams wanted for Fleury. Then had a much better team going forward.
Well obviously not for nothing because it quite directly forced them to trade their number 2 DVegas got a number 1 D for nothing. Easy come, easy go.
It is not at all equivalent to that. That is the route they chose to bring Pie in but there were other ways to make salaries work that didn't rely on moving a top 4 defensemen. They very easily could have kept Schmidt and then getting Pietrangelo is a pure upgrade on their defense.So this trade obviously looks horrible and is horrible.. BUT...
The net result of this trade is:
Schmidt
For
Pietro
3rd
So if you look at the whole thing it doesn't seem as bad. NOT trying to defend the trade.. I think they should have gotten more than a 3rd, but still, it doesn't look as bad when looking at the big picture.
which makes what Vancouver has done more impressive.Two teams that went through a rebuild for 500, Alex.
Vancouver didn’t, an apples to Iphones comparison.
Your blind hatred towards Jimbo is comical. This is a steal of the deal unless you are not watching any games.Even more cap hell, bennings favourite. Clearly Scmitty was over rated on here if no one out bid Jimbo.
Yeah, it was a dumb contract, but we didn’t have to let him go. But congrats. You got Vegas Pietrangelo.
They gave up an asset to help their divisional rival sign a top 5 defenseman and all they got was Nate Schmidt
Schmidt is a nice player, I just don't like the contract.
what more does Jim Benning have to do to get a little respect?
Steals a very good dman for nothing from Vegas, gets a revelation in JT Miller, drafts franchise C, franchise D, and a potential franchise winger and has built a better team than Toronto or Edmonton in the same amount of time despite never having a top 3 lotto pick
but some people go on about how he signed Jay f***ing Beagle and Antoine Roussel?
two-way contracts wouldn't effect that at all. They just mean the player has a different salary while in the AHLLiterally impossible.
EDIT without two way contracts.
Yeah, it was a dumb contract, but we didn’t have to let him go. But congrats. You got Vegas Pietrangelo.
They gave up an asset to help their divisional rival sign a top 5 defenseman and all they got was Nate Schmidt
I guess not signing Tanev and Stecher makes more sense now.Schmidt’s a good dman, but he makes 6 million. There’s not a lot of teams that can take him, that wouldn’t be in his NTC list. Good job by Benning to capitalize
This aged. Good on Benning we doubted him and he pulled through.
Shiny new toy syndrome.Is petro so much better than him that all this chaos is worth it?
which makes what Vancouver has done more impressive.
The lads couldn't even get the benefit of trading their 2 most tradable assets and get extra 1sts/2nds to help for the retool in the Sedins.
They didn't tank for half a decade or rely on ping pong balls to find their goods.
Did it with good scouting and shrewd moves. If Demko is real, they are set